Could Dune's Ornithopter Actually Fly? The Physics Of Flapping Wings The Size Of A Bus

Table of Contents (click to expand)

A flapping aircraft the size of Dune's ornithopter could fly, but only by beating its enormous wings about twice a second, the pace of a large bird rather than a dragonfly, and it would need helicopter-class engines just to hover. The one on screen flaps about thirty times a second, a rate the film's animators chose so the wings read as a blur; at that pace the tips of a 20-meter wing would pass the speed of sound and the forces trying to tear the wings off would be more than two hundred times those at a realistic pace. Real ornithopters exist, including a piloted full-scale flight in 2006 and a human-powered record flight four years later, and all of them flap slowly.

Early in Dune: Part One, an ornithopter lifts off from Arrakeen. The wings start, and within a second they blur into a shimmer on either side of the hull. The thing rises like a dragonfly that happens to weigh as much as a bus.

It is the most convincing aircraft in science fiction since the X-wing, so people argue about it. On one physics forum this autumn, two friends argued it over three dozen comments. One said insects manage it, so a machine built the same way should too. The other said not at that size, without being able to say why.

Both were half right, and the numbers are more fun than a yes or a no.

How Does A Flapping Wing Actually Fly?

Hold your hand flat out of a car window and tilt the front edge up. The air shoves it upward. That shove is lift, and it only exists while air moves past the surface.

An airplane drags its whole body forward with an engine. A bird moves the wing instead. Each downstroke sweeps the wing through the air fast enough to push air down and back. One stroke does both jobs, so an ornithopter (a machine that flies by flapping) needs no propeller.

Think of oars: a child in a dinghy takes short, quick strokes with a small paddle. A rowing eight takes long, slow strokes with oars the length of a car. The big oar moves far more water per stroke, so it can afford to be slow. Wings work the same way, and how fast you must flap depends on the size of the wing and the weight it carries.

A ruddy darter dragonfly at rest. In flight its four wings beat around thirty to forty times a second. The wings weigh almost nothing, which turns out to be the whole trick. (Photo Credit: Jörg Hempel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE)
A ruddy darter dragonfly at rest. In flight its four wings beat around thirty to forty times a second. The wings weigh almost nothing, which turns out to be the whole trick. (Photo Credit: Jörg Hempel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE)

Why Do Bigger Flyers Flap Slower?

Watch a swan take off and count, and you will get a few beats a second. A sparrow is too fast to count, and a dragonfly is a blur. Every flyer in between sits on the same steep slope.

There is a classic scaling rule for this. Build an exact copy of a flyer at a larger scale, same proportions throughout. Its wingbeat rate falls with the sixth root of its mass, written out as:

new rate = old rate × (old mass ÷ new mass)1/6

The sixth root is gentle, so a million times the mass means only ten times slower. The same pattern holds for over four hundred measured animals, mosquito to swan. Run it for the largest flying animal ever, a pterosaur as heavy as a man, and the predicted wingbeat is under once a second.

So scale a dragonfly up to an ornithopter. One measured dragonfly weighed a third of a gram and flapped about 28 times a second.

  1. The big practical ornithopter built for the film weighed about 13 tonnes. That is 38 million times the insect.
  2. The sixth root of that is about 18.
  3. Divide the insect's rate by it, and the scaled-up machine flaps about 1.6 times a second.

A lighter three-tonne craft comes out at two beats a second. Either way, physics says a flap every half second or so, the tempo of a heron. The same wall keeps humans from flapping themselves aloft and caps how big a flying dragon could be.

The scaling rule, drawn out. Start from a measured dragonfly and grow it to bus size without changing its shape, and the wingbeat falls to under two a second. The dashed line is what the film shows.
The scaling rule, drawn out. Start from a measured dragonfly and grow it to bus size without changing its shape, and the wingbeat falls to under two a second. The dashed line is what the film shows.

How Fast Would Dune's Ornithopter Have To Flap To Hover?

A group of physics students at the University of Leicester took a different road and landed in the same place.

From the size of the actors, they put the film craft's wings at 20 meters long and gave it eight of them. Then they asked how fast such plates must beat downward to lift three tonnes. Their answer was 1.78 flaps per second for each wing.

They also worked out the power: about 182 horsepower per wing, so roughly 1,460 horsepower for eight. Their yardstick helicopter carries the same number of people on two 560-horsepower engines. The students called their figure a serious underestimate. It ignores the wings' weight and the cost of reversing them. A helicopter dodges that problem: its blades never reverse, they just go round.

Two independent routes, one from biology and one from drag on a flat plate, both land near two beats a second. The ornithopter in the book and the film is not impossible. It is slow.

The Leicester students' yardstick: an Agusta A109 hovering on two engines of about 560 horsepower each. Their flat-plate ornithopter needed more than that just to hold still, and they called the figure an underestimate. (Photo Credit: Ikiwaner, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
The Leicester students' yardstick: an Agusta A109 hovering on two engines of about 560 horsepower each. Their flat-plate ornithopter needed more than that just to hold still, and they called the figure an underestimate. (Photo Credit: Ikiwaner, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

What Happens To The Wings At 30 Beats Per Second?

The film did not go slow. Robyn Luckham, DNEG's animation director, described the wing motion in an interview. Each wing "moves in a figure eight like a bird" and "goes about 30 times a second, or a frame." They also, in his words, "widened the wingspans" so the craft looked able to lift itself.

Thirty beats a second on a 20-meter wing is where the physics stops being polite. The wingtip is the fastest-moving part. For a smooth back-and-forth stroke its peak speed is:

peak tip speed = half the stroke angle × 2π × beats per second × wing length

Take that wing swinging through a modest twenty-degree arc.

  1. Half the stroke is ten degrees, or 0.17 radians.
  2. At two beats a second the tip peaks near 44 meters per second.
  3. At thirty beats a second it peaks near 660 meters per second. The speed of sound at sea level is about 340 meters per second, so that is Mach 1.9.

The tips go supersonic at around sixteen beats a second. Drag and noise pile up fast near the speed of sound, which is the same wall that caps a propeller. At the film's tempo, eight tips would cross the sound barrier twice per stroke. A sonic boom would announce the Atreides before they landed.

Speed is the smaller problem, because the wing must stop and reverse at the end of every stroke. The force needed grows with the square of the beat rate. Fifteen times the tempo means 225 times the force at the wing root. Power grows with the cube of the rate, so the same jump multiplies it by more than three thousand. A root fitting sized for two beats a second would not survive the first stroke at thirty.

Peak wingtip speed against flapping rate for two plausible wing geometries. At the film's tempo both cross the speed of sound with room to spare. At the physics tempo, neither gets close.
Peak wingtip speed against flapping rate for two plausible wing geometries. At the film's tempo both cross the speed of sound with room to spare. At the physics tempo, neither gets close.

Why Can A Dragonfly Do What A 13-Tonne Machine Cannot?

So how does the insect get away with it? There are two reasons, and neither scales up.

First, insect wings weigh almost nothing. The lightest dragonfly and damselfly wings come in at about seven grams per square meter. That is thinner than printer paper. When a wing that light reverses, the air pushing on it matters more than its own inertia. A bus-length wing built to carry soldiers cannot be made of nothing. It will weigh hundreds of kilograms, all of it stopping and restarting on every beat.

Second, an insect wing is a spring with a natural bounce. At the stroke used in flight, that bounce matches the wingbeat. The wing stores energy at the end of each stroke and gives it back on the way out, like a diving board. A carbon-fiber spar the length of a bus has a natural bounce too, but nowhere near thirty a second. Tuning it there would make the wing far too stiff and heavy.

Put plainly, the dragonfly is cheating and getting away with it. Every reversal of a heavy machine wing is paid for in full.

A slender skimmer dragonfly in the sun. You can read the wall through its wings. A membrane this thin reverses direction thirty times a second because the air, not the wing's own weight, does most of the braking. (Photo Credit: Iamdev37, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
A slender skimmer dragonfly in the sun. You can read the wall through its wings. A membrane this thin reverses direction thirty times a second because the air, not the wing's own weight, does most of the braking. (Photo Credit: Iamdev37, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Has Anyone Ever Built A Real Ornithopter?

Yes, and all of them flap slowly.

Leonardo da Vinci drew the first serious designs. Most of his flying machines were ornithopters, worked by the pilot's arms, legs, or both. The Smithsonian's aviation curators are blunt about why none could have flown. The barrier is "the demonstrably limited muscle power and endurance of humans compared to birds." He never built one, and by 1505 his notebooks had moved on to how birds glide, the more useful idea.

One of Leonardo's flapping-wing designs. The wings were fine. The engine, a human being, was not. (Photo Credit: Leonardo da Vinci, Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
One of Leonardo's flapping-wing designs. The wings were fine. The engine, a human being, was not. (Photo Credit: Leonardo da Vinci, Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

The engine problem was solved in Toronto. James DeLaurier's group there flew the world's first full-scale, piloted ornithopter in 2006. A small jet helped it off the ground. Four years later two of his students tried muscle power. Their Snowbird had a wingspan of 32 meters, wider than an airliner. It weighed about 43 kilograms, less than its pilot. A car towed it up to speed and let go. It then held altitude on flapping power alone for just over nineteen seconds. The world air-sports federation certified it as the first human-powered flapping flight.

The Snowbird was biomimicry done properly: the physics of a large bird rather than the look of a small insect.

The Snowbird on display at the Canada Aviation and Space Museum. A 32-meter span, 43 kilograms, and a pilot pedaling for every meter of its nineteen-second record. (Photo Credit: Ahunt, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)
The Snowbird on display at the Canada Aviation and Space Museum. A 32-meter span, 43 kilograms, and a pilot pedaling for every meter of its nineteen-second record. (Photo Credit: Ahunt, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)

So, Could Dune's Ornithopter Actually Fly?

Yes, with two conditions the film quietly ignores.

A flapping aircraft of several tonnes can fly if its wings are enormous and it beats them about twice a second. That figure comes from a scaling rule built on hundreds of real animals. A flat-plate estimate that never mentions an animal gives the same answer. It would need helicopter-class power to hover, and more once the wings weigh as much as cars. It would also, in principle, work, and Frank Herbert's machine is not the problem.

What cannot fly is the one on screen. At thirty beats a second the tips are supersonic and the reversal forces are hundreds of times too high. The power to drive them runs to billions of watts. The craft would shed its wings before it cleared the pad. Dragonflies survive that tempo with wings lighter than paper that bounce in time. A hull full of soldiers can borrow neither trick.

The animators knew this. They widened the wings so the machine looked able to lift itself, then kept the blur because it looked alive. Slow the wings to two beats a second and the ornithopter would read as a large, anxious bird. The physics would be right and the shot would be worse.

So enjoy the shimmer over Arrakeen twice: as filmmaking, and as a flap rate physics would bill in gigawatts. The real thing, if anyone builds it, will beat its wings slowly enough for you to count.

References (click to expand)
  1. What is Lift? NASA Glenn Research Center, Beginner's Guide to Aeronautics
  2. Speed of Sound. NASA Glenn Research Center, Beginner's Guide to Aeronautics
  3. Leonardo da Vinci and Flight. Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum
  4. Wingbeat frequency of birds in steady cruising flight: new data and improved predictions. Journal of Experimental Biology (Pennycuick, 1996)
  5. Scaling of wingbeat frequency with body mass in bats and limits to maximum bat size. Journal of Experimental Biology (Norberg and Norberg, 2012)
  6. Universal wing- and fin-beat frequency scaling. PLOS ONE (2024), via PubMed Central
  7. Kinematics and Aerodynamics of Dragonflies (Pantala flavescens, Libellulidae) in Climbing Flight. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology (2022), via PubMed Central
  8. Subtle frequency matching reveals resonant phenomenon in the flight of Odonata. Journal of the Royal Society Interface (2024), via PubMed Central
  9. Flying and swimming animals cruise at a Strouhal number tuned for high power efficiency. Nature (2003)
  10. A5_1 Exploration of Dune's Ornithopters. Journal of Physics Special Topics, University of Leicester (undergraduate journal, 2022)
  11. Director Denis Villeneuve maintains a grounded approach to epic space saga Dune. VFX Voice, Visual Effects Society (2021)
  12. 'Dune': The Inner Workings of Ornithopters, Sand Worms, and Creative Moviemaking. Animation World Network (2022)
  13. Helicopter blade tips. NASA Technical Reports Server, NASA-TM-77370 (1983)
  14. 2010 & 2013: UTIAS Alumni Todd Reichert and Cameron Robertson Make Two Historic Flights. University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies
  15. International aviation body confirms human-powered ornithopter achievement. University of Toronto Engineering News
  16. First human powered aircraft with flapping wings. Guinness World Records
  17. The Flapper: Toronto's ornithopter. CBC News In Depth (2006)