Why Do Phillips Screwdrivers Cam Out? The Real Reason The Bit Slips

Table of Contents (click to expand)
Phillips screwdrivers slip out of the screw, an effect called cam-out, because the four walls of the cross are cut on a slight slope. Twist hard enough and that slope turns part of your effort into an upward lift that climbs the bit out of the cross. The popular claim that Henry Phillips built the screw to slip on purpose is a myth, because his own patents list a driver with “no tendency to cam out” as a main goal, and the real aim was a screw that centers itself under fast factory power tools.

Picture the last time you built flat-pack furniture. You are on the final panel, you lean into a Phillips screw, the driver bites, and then it happens. The bit climbs up out of the cross with a nasty crunch and skids across the wood. The little cross is now a chewed-up mess, and the screw is going nowhere.

You have just been beaten by a piece of hardware that costs less than a cent. And if you go looking for why, you will meet the same tidy answer everywhere. Henry Phillips, the story goes, designed the screw to slip on purpose, a built-in safety valve to stop factory workers overtightening.

It is a great story. It is also wrong, and the proof is sitting in Phillips' own patents. Let us start with what is actually happening in that stripped little cross.

What Does It Mean When A Screwdriver "Cams Out"?

Engineers have a name for that sickening slip: they call it "cam out."

Cam out is when the bit climbs up and out of the screw head while you are turning it. Below a certain amount of twist the bit stays put, and above it the bit climbs the walls of the cross and is gone.

The word "cam" is the clue. A cam is a shaped surface that turns a push in one direction into a push in another, and the simplest cam you know is a ramp: push a crate along one and part of your push becomes lift. Your Phillips screw plays that trick on you, turning your twist into a lift that carries the bit out.

To see why, it helps to know that a screw is a ramp from top to bottom. Unroll the thread winding up the shaft in your mind and you get a long, gentle slope: a ramp wrapped around a cylinder, in the textbook phrase. That rolled-up ramp is what makes a screw useful. Turn the head and the thread pulls the screw forward into the wood, so a gentle twist becomes a strong forward squeeze. The screw turns a turning force, which engineers call torque, into a force along its length.

But a ramp can also turn your twist into a lift you did not ask for. In a Phillips head, a second set of little ramps hides in the cross itself, and those are the ones that bite you.

Unroll a screw thread and you get a plain ramp. That is all a screw is, a ramp wound around a rod.
Unroll a screw thread and you get a plain ramp. That is all a screw is, a ramp wound around a rod.

So Why Does A Phillips Bit Climb Out Of The Cross?

Look closely at the four arms of a Phillips cross. The walls are not straight up and down. Each one is cut on a slight slope, so the cross is a touch wider at the top than at the bottom. Each wall is a tiny ramp.

Now push your bit in and twist, and your force lands on those sloped walls. A ramp can only do one thing with a sideways push, which is to split it. Part of your effort goes where you want, around, turning the screw. The rest goes where you do not, straight up the slope, lifting the bit.

That lift is the villain. At low force it is small, and friction and your grip hold the bit down while the screw turns. But the harder the screw fights back, the harder you twist, and the harder you twist, the bigger the lift grows. Pass the tipping point and the lift wins. The bit climbs the slopes and is out, and the soft metal of the cross gets shredded on the way. That is a cruel joke to play near the end of the job.

The wall of the cross is sloped, so part of a twist becomes a lift that climbs the bit out of the cross.
The wall of the cross is sloped, so part of a twist becomes a lift that climbs the bit out of the cross.

Did Henry Phillips Design The Screw To Slip On Purpose?

The famous story goes like this. On a fast car assembly line, a worker with a power tool could crank a screw too tight and snap it. So Phillips, the tale says, designed the cross to cam out on purpose. Once the screw was snug, the bit would climb free and warn the worker to stop. The slip, in this telling, is a safety feature rather than a flaw.

It is a lovely story, and you can see why it spread. There is only one problem. The people who wrote the patents said the exact opposite, and we do not have to guess, because patents are public.

Start with the patent filed in 1935 for the screw itself. It lists the goals of the design in plain words, and one of them is a screw head shaped for a firm grip on the driver. The patent's phrase is blunt: there should be "no tendency of the driver to cam out of the recess." The inventors treated slipping as a defect to design away. It is hard to build a feature on purpose while writing "no tendency" toward it into your own patent.

So where did the "camming" idea come from? A second patent does use the word, but not the way the myth claims. It describes a "camming action" that pushes grit and dirt out of the cross, so a speck of dust cannot stop the bit seating. In the same patent, the goal for the driver is the reverse of slipping. The driver, it says, is "locked in its proper centralized working relation with the screw," and the danger of it leaving is "thus entirely eliminated."

That is the smoking gun. In the patents, camming means clearing debris, and the driver is meant to lock in and stay. The whole legend rests on a word that meant something else.

US Patent 2,046,839, granted July 7, 1936. The screw whose own patent lists "no tendency to cam out" as a goal.
US Patent 2,046,839, granted July 7, 1936. The screw whose own patent lists "no tendency to cam out" as a goal.

Who Really Invented The Phillips Screw?

Henry Phillips did not even invent the Phillips screw.

The cross-shaped screw was dreamed up by an Oregon man named John P. Thompson, who filed patents for the screw and its driver in 1932. He had spotted a real problem. The old slotted screw, with its single straight groove, was a pain on a fast line: hard to line up, and the bit slid out the open ends. A cross fixed both.

But Thompson could not sell it, because manufacturers were not interested. So the rights passed to Henry Phillips, then a manager at an Oregon mining firm, who had the salesmanship Thompson lacked. He set up the Phillips Screw Company and talked a screw maker into producing the thing.

His pitch was never "it slips." His pitch was that the screw centers itself. Point a power driver at a cross and it drops into place on its own, even if your aim is a little off. On a moving line, that saves a second on every screw, and there are a lot of screws in a car. General Motors bit. They tested Phillips screws on the line and built the 1936 Cadillac with them. By 1940, 85 percent of American screw makers had licensed the design. The selling point was speed and self-centering, and slipping was never in the sales brochure.

So where does the myth come from? Myths usually grow from a seed of truth, and this one does too. Phillips screws did slip, and the inventors knew it. Then something unplanned happened on those assembly lines. The early power tools had crude clutches, the part that is meant to stop the tool once the screw is tight, and they kept twisting when they should have quit.

On those tools, the slip turned out to be handy. When the clutch failed, the screw would cam out and save itself from being cranked to death. A flaw became a lucky backup, and over the years people saw the useful result and assumed it was the plan all along. Cam-out was never the goal. It was a tolerated side effect that sometimes helped, and helpfulness got mistaken for intent.

A 1936 Cadillac Series 60. Phillips screws helped put cars like this together, one self-centering cross at a time. (Photo Credit: New York Public Library, Wikimedia Commons, no known copyright restrictions)
A 1936 Cadillac Series 60. Phillips screws helped put cars like this together, one self-centering cross at a time. (Photo Credit: New York Public Library, Wikimedia Commons, no known copyright restrictions)

Which Screw Heads Grip Instead Of Slipping?

If sloped walls cause the slip, the obvious fix is to get rid of the slope. That is what the better drives did, and it is why serious workshops have mostly moved on from Phillips.

Take the Robertson screw, the one with a square hole. It was made by a Canadian, Peter Robertson, and it is everywhere in Canada. Its walls are nearly straight, so there is barely any slope for the bit to climb. A Robertson bit sits down in the square and grips. It even holds the screw on the tip by itself, so you can drive one-handed, and it slips far less often than a Phillips.

Pozidriv took the cross and fixed its walls. It looks like a Phillips at a glance, but where the Phillips walls are sloped, the Pozidriv walls are straight. Straight walls do not split your twist into a lift, so the bit stays down.

Then there is Torx, the six-pointed star you see on electronics and cars. Its lobes are close to straight-walled, so almost none of your twist becomes lift. Torx carries far more twist than a cross and resists cam-out by design, which is why it is the pick for heavy work.

Slotted, Phillips, Robertson, Pozidriv, Torx. The square and the star have straight walls, so they grip where the cross slips.
Slotted, Phillips, Robertson, Pozidriv, Torx. The square and the star have straight walls, so they grip where the cross slips.

So Why Do We Still Use Phillips Screws Everywhere?

If Robertson and Torx grip so much better, why is your junk drawer still full of Phillips screws? Why does the screw with the known flaw still win?

Because the flaw and the strength are the same shape. The sloped walls that lift the bit out are also the ramps that guide it in. The self-centering that sold the screw to General Motors is still the best thing about it. For most jobs, a hinge, a light switch cover, a bookshelf, you do not need much force. You need to seat a screw fast and move on, and a Phillips does that for almost nothing.

It is cheap to make, easy to find, and forgiving to aim, and "good enough and cheap" is a hard combination to beat. The everyday hardware around you is a long list of good-enough winners.

So the next time a Phillips bit climbs out and chews up a screw, you can let go of the myth. Nobody engineered that slip to teach you a lesson. It is just a ramp, doing the one thing ramps do, at the worst possible moment. For a stubborn job, a Robertson or Torx screw will hold the bit far better.

References (click to expand)
  1. Cam out — Wikipedia
  2. List of screw drives — Wikipedia
  3. Simple Machines: Screw — EBSCO Research Starters
  4. U.S. Patent 2,046,839, "Screw" (Phillips & Fitzpatrick, 1936) — Google Patents
  5. U.S. Patent 2,046,837, "Means for Uniting a Screw with a Driver" (Phillips, 1936) — Google Patents
  6. Phillips Screw and Driver — The Oregon Encyclopedia
  7. Henry Phillips — National Inventors Hall of Fame
  8. Peter Lymburner Robertson — Wikipedia