Where Does Light's Energy Go When It Is Cosmologically Redshifted?

Table of Contents (click to expand)

Light from a distant galaxy arrives with its waves stretched, and longer waves carry less energy, so light stretched eight times over reaches us with one-eighth of the energy it started with. The missing energy does not go anywhere, because the universe has no grand total of energy for it to go missing from: energy only stays constant when the rules of physics work the same today as yesterday, and an expanding universe changes as it ages. Energy is still perfectly safe inside any small patch of space, which is why none of this changes anything on Earth.

In July 2022, the first deep-field image from the James Webb Space Telescope went public: a scrap of sky about the size of a grain of sand held at arm's length, packed with galaxies. Their light set out as visible and ultraviolet light and arrived as infrared, which is exactly why Webb was built to see in infrared.

Infrared light carries a lot less energy than ultraviolet light. So a photon (a single particle of light) left home 13 billion years ago and handed the telescope a fraction of what it set out with.

Energy is not supposed to just vanish. Your science teacher was not lying to you. So where did the rest of it go? There are three confident answers, repeated everywhere. All three are wrong. The real one is stranger, and better.

Webb's first deep field, centered on galaxy cluster SMACS 0723. Nearly every smudge here is a galaxy, and nearly every photon in the frame arrived stretched. (Photo Credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, and STScI)
Webb's first deep field, centered on galaxy cluster SMACS 0723. Nearly every smudge here is a galaxy, and nearly every photon in the frame arrived stretched. (Photo Credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, and STScI)

What Is Cosmological Redshift, And Does The Light Really Lose Energy?

Light travels as a wave, and the distance between two neighboring crests is its wavelength. Wavelength is what your eye reads as color: long waves look red, short waves look blue, and shorter still is ultraviolet, where your eye stops being consulted.

Wavelength is energy. A stretched wave carries less energy than a short one.

Light that crosses a huge stretch of space arrives with a longer wavelength than it started with. Astronomers call this cosmological redshift, and they keep score with a number called z. Add 1 to z, and that is how many times longer the wave got.

stretched wavelength = (1 + z) × original wavelength

So z = 1 means the wave doubled. That is the whole toolkit: stretch the wave, and you have lowered the energy.

One wave, stretched and released. The arrow always spans exactly one wavelength, and the energy bar is doing nothing more than 1 divided by that number.
One wave, stretched and released. The arrow always spans exactly one wavelength, and the energy bar is doing nothing more than 1 divided by that number.

Take a galaxy at z = 7. Its light arrives eight times longer than it left, so it carries eight times less energy. The photon shows up with one-eighth of what it set off with. Seven-eighths never makes it onto the invoice.

The most stretched light we know of is the cosmic microwave background, the leftover glow of the young universe. It set out at about 3,000 degrees above absolute zero and reaches us at about 2.7 degrees above absolute zero. Those waves got stretched about 1,100 times over. Three popular answers try to explain the difference.

Does The Energy Go Into Stretching Space?

This is the answer you meet first. Space itself expands, dragging the light wave along costs energy, and the photon pays. The scientists who study this for a living cannot stand it.

To see why, you need one idea. Measuring anything means picking a starting point. Your desk is two meters from the window. The same desk is four meters from the door. You changed where you measured from, and the desk did not budge.

Physicists call those choices labels, and nothing real ever depends on them. The expansion of the universe lives in the labels. Astronomers label space with a ruler that grows as the universe grows, but a growing ruler is not a growing force. It cannot grab anything. One cosmologist calls this "the 'expanding space' fallacy," a polite way of saying people have been fooled by their own ruler.

Now zoom in on one meter of the light's journey. In a patch that small, everything looks completely ordinary, with no stretching going on anywhere and nothing pulling on the light. So "expanding space" describes what we see. It does not cause it.

The standard 13.8-billion-year expansion diagram. Excellent bookkeeping, and not a picture of a force acting on anything. (Photo Credit: NASA / WMAP Science Team)
The standard 13.8-billion-year expansion diagram. Excellent bookkeeping, and not a picture of a force acting on anything. (Photo Credit: NASA / WMAP Science Team)

Does The Energy Become Gravitational Energy, Or Work Done On The Universe?

Answer two: the energy was handed over to gravity, the way a ball you throw upward trades speed for height. The problem is that gravity's energy has no address.

For everything else in physics you can point at a spot and say how much energy is sitting right there. Gravity refuses to play along, and when physicists try anyway, the labels come back to bite. Pick one set of labels and the math claims there is gravitational energy sitting in totally empty space. Pick a different set and the same energy "can be made zero at any chosen point." An answer that vanishes when you change your labels is not an answer. It is a filing system.

Answer three gets closest to being right before it goes wrong. Press the plunger of a bicycle pump and the air inside gets warmer. Gas that gets squeezed gains energy, and gas that expands loses it. Physicists can write down a matching equation for the whole universe as it grows, and it works: it correctly predicts that light thins out faster than ordinary matter does. Matter just gets spread thinner; light gets spread thinner and loses energy to stretching on top. So light does work like gas pushing a plunger, and the energy goes into the push.

Now find the plunger. When gas expands it pushes on something: a piston or a balloon wall. But the universe is not expanding into anything. There is no wall, no outside, nothing receiving the push. The math is right. The story is made up.

Why Is Energy Conserved At All? Noether's Theorem

Nobody ever tells you why energy cannot vanish. But it does have a reason, and a mathematician named Emmy Noether worked it out in 1918. Her discovery was this: every rule about something staying constant comes from something else staying boring.

Move your lab a mile east and the laws of physics are identical. Run your test next week instead of today and they are identical again. Those are the boring bits, and Noether proved that each one hands you a quantity that cannot change. Because physics is the same here as over there, momentum can never change. Because physics is the same today as it was yesterday, energy can never change. Energy stays constant because yesterday and today run by identical rules.

Our universe was smaller yesterday and it will be bigger tomorrow, so today genuinely is not the same as yesterday. The boring bit is gone, and when the boring bit goes, so does the rule that came from it. One cosmologist puts it about as bluntly as anyone: the only reason you ever thought energy was conserved was that yesterday matched today. In our universe, it does not.

So "where did the energy go?" quietly assumes the universe has a grand total of energy, that this total is a fixed number, and that the photon's missing share got subtracted from it. There is no such number.

Emmy Noether. Her 1918 theorem is why anyone can say why energy is conserved, rather than just that it is. (Photo Credit: Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)
Emmy Noether. Her 1918 theorem is why anyone can say why energy is conserved, rather than just that it is. (Photo Credit: Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

So, Where Does Light's Energy Go When It Is Cosmologically Redshifted?

At this point it is easy to decide physics has sprung a leak. It has not. The first law of thermodynamics has not been canceled. Energy conservation comes in two sizes, and only the small one survives.

The small version: energy cannot appear or disappear inside any small patch of space. This one is rock solid, everywhere, always, no exceptions. It is why nothing here threatens your kettle, a rocket launch, or your chemistry homework.

The big version: add up all the energy in the entire universe and that grand total stays fixed. This is the one that fails. Adding things up means comparing something measured here with something measured a billion light years away, in space that has been stretching the whole time your measurement was traveling. There is no agreed way to line those two numbers up. So the grand total is not defined and then broken. It was never defined in the first place.

There is a second half to this puzzle that almost nobody worries about. Empty space holds a faint amount of energy, called dark energy, and every cubic meter of space holds the same amount of it. Make more space and you have made more dark energy, so the grand total climbs, forever. Nobody writes worried posts asking where all that new energy is coming from. Once there is no fixed grand total, it is free to fall or to climb.

So where does the light's energy go? Nowhere. Not because it got destroyed, but because "where did it go" is a question about a grand total that was never there to take from.

The stretching is really a huge pile of ordinary Doppler shifts, the same effect that drops an ambulance siren's pitch as it passes. Picture a long line of observers from that galaxy to your telescope, each drifting slowly away from the one behind and each seeing the light a little redder than the one before. Stack up billions of years of those tiny shifts and you get the full stretch.

Throw a ball on a moving train. To you, sitting on the train, it is a gentle toss. To someone on the platform, that same ball is hurtling along with far more energy, and nobody demands to know where the extra came from. It is the desk again. Energy has always been a number you measure from somewhere, two meters from the window or four from the door. This light was released by one observer and caught by another, and those two have been drifting apart for 13 billion years.

Physicists do still argue about how to word all this. Some insist energy really is conserved, if you define your terms carefully enough. That argument is real, and it is an argument about vocabulary. Nobody disagrees about what the light does, or about what the telescope reads.

Back to the oldest light there is. It set out glowing at 3,000 degrees and arrives barely above absolute zero. That drop is not a theft and it is not a leak. It is simply what light does in a universe that is not the same today as it was yesterday. How fast our universe is expanding is a genuinely open question. This one is not. It is just a much better question than it first looks.

The whole sky in microwaves. This light left at 3,000 K and arrives at 2.725 K, which is the largest redshift anyone has ever measured. (Photo Credit: NASA / WMAP Science Team)
The whole sky in microwaves. This light left at 3,000 K and arrives at 2.725 K, which is the largest redshift anyone has ever measured. (Photo Credit: NASA / WMAP Science Team)
References (click to expand)
  1. Bunn, E. F. and Hogg, D. W., "The kinematic origin of the cosmological redshift," American Journal of Physics 77, 688-694 (2009)
  2. Peacock, J. A., "A diatribe on expanding space" (2008)
  3. Weiss, M. and Baez, J., "Is Energy Conserved in General Relativity?" University of California, Riverside Physics FAQ
  4. Carroll, S., "Energy Is Not Conserved" (2010)
  5. Trodden, M. and Carroll, S. M., "TASI Lectures: Introduction to Cosmology"
  6. Noether's theorems, in "Symmetry and Symmetry Breaking," Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  7. COBE Science, NASA
  8. Anatomy of an Electromagnetic Wave, NASA Science
  9. Why the microwave, ESA / Planck
  10. Cosmological Redshift, COSMOS, Swinburne University of Technology
  11. Infrared Astronomy, NASA Webb Science Explainers