How Did Early Chemists Catch Watered-Down "Swill Milk"?

Table of Contents (click to expand)
Nineteenth-century milk was watered far more often than it was doctored with chalk: when London's milk was tested in the early 1850s, eleven of twenty-six dairies were selling milk cut with ten to fifty percent water, and not one sample contained chalk. Chemists caught each cheat by measuring the thing it changed: a glass float showed that watered milk is lighter, a drop of iodine turned flour-thickened milk blue, and from 1890 the Babcock test dissolved everything except the fat in sulfuric acid and spun it into a graduated neck so milk could be paid for by its cream. Every one of those tests measured a stand-in for quality rather than quality itself, which is why skimming the cream before adding water could fool the float, and why melamine fooled protein tests in 2008.

A PBS film, The Poison Squad, sums up the milk of the 1800s in two lines. The standard recipe, the narrator says, was a pint of warm water for every quart of milk. That left the milk bluish, so dairies stirred in whitening agents such as plaster of Paris or chalk.

The story has everything. In 1858 Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper went after the "swill milk" dairies of New York. It ran two furious articles. The cows stood chained in sheds beside distilleries and ate the hot mash left over from the stills. One campaigner had already guessed at ten thousand such cows in the city. They were, he wrote, "most inhumanly condemned to subsist on the residuum or slush of this grain." A physician went further. Eight or nine thousand of the city's children under five died each year, he said. A large share of them, he claimed, were poisoned by their milk. The outrage got New York its first law against milk adulteration two years later. A ban on distillery-fed milk followed a few years after that.

Here is the problem with that story. The men who went looking for chalk in milk did not find any. What they found, over and over, was water. And water turned out to be the better puzzle. The obvious test for it could be beaten by a dairyman who knew no chemistry at all.

Why Does Watered-Down Milk Look Blue?

Hold a glass of skim milk up to a window and you will see it: a faint blue cast that whole milk does not have. The cheats of the 1850s saw it too, which is why the whitening rumor exists at all. The color comes down to the size of the particles floating in the milk.

Milk is water with two kinds of particles suspended in it. The big ones are droplets of fat, a few thousandths of a millimeter across. The small ones are clumps of a protein called casein. They are roughly a hundred times smaller than the fat droplets. Neither kind dissolves, so both stay suspended. They hang in the water and bounce light around. That bouncing is why milk is white and opaque, while whey is clear.

How light bounces depends on particle size. A particle scatters light best when the light's wavelength is close to its own size. Fat droplets are far bigger than any wavelength of visible light. They scatter every color about equally, and the mix comes back white. Casein clumps are closer in size to blue light than to red, so they scatter blue more than red. Skim the fat off and only the small scatterers remain. The glass takes on a blue tinge. It is the same physics that turns the sky blue and lights up a sunbeam in a dusty room.

Whole milk scatters every color and looks white. Take the fat out, and the small protein particles that remain scatter blue light more than red.
Whole milk scatters every color and looks white. Take the fat out, and the small protein particles that remain scatter blue light more than red.

Water makes it worse. Dilute milk and the particles thin out. The glass goes from white to watery to faintly blue, and the customer notices. One French chemist of the day put it bluntly. Skimming alone gives milk "a flimsy look, so to speak, together with a bluish tinge." Watering increases it, and "in order to mask the two previous impositions, a third, fourth, or even fifth must be practised." That chain, cheat then cover then cover the cover, sums up milk fraud. Each cover-up changes something physical about the milk, and anything physical can be measured.

Why Couldn't A Hydrometer Catch Watered Milk?

The obvious thing to measure is weight. Milk is heavier than water, because the sugar, protein and minerals dissolved in it add mass. Pour a liter of each and the milk weighs about 1,030 grams against water's 1,000. Chemists call that ratio specific gravity, and for genuine milk it sits around 1.030.

You do not need a balance to read it. A hydrometer is a weighted glass float with a graduated stem. Drop it in a liquid and it sinks until it has pushed aside its own weight of liquid. That is the same rule that decides whether ice floats. In a dense liquid the float rides high. In a thin one it sinks deep. Add water to milk and the float drops. French measurements of the period gave the number: milk at 1.031 fell to 1.021 once a quarter of its volume was water.

A hydrometer. The weighted bulb sinks until the float has pushed aside its own weight of liquid, so it rides higher in milk than in water. (Photo Credit: Jacek Halicki, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
A hydrometer. The weighted bulb sinks until the float has pushed aside its own weight of liquid, so it rides higher in milk than in water. (Photo Credit: Jacek Halicki, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

So far, so easy for the chemist. The catch, as ever with milk, is the cream. Fat is lighter than water, which is why cream rises. It is also why rich milk reads lower on a hydrometer than poor milk. Skim the cream off and the float rides higher, not lower. A dairyman who skimmed first and watered second could land his milk right back in the normal range. Arthur Hill Hassall tabulated genuine milks for The Lancet and found that richness often ran "in an inverse ratio" to density. He called the specific gravity test "highly fallacious." The float was honest; it had just been asked the wrong question.

Water sinks the float. Skimming lifts it. Do both and the reading lands back in the honest range.
Water sinks the float. Skimming lifts it. Do both and the reading lands back in the honest range.

Hassall's fix was to measure the part of milk that cheats cannot touch. Curdle the milk and strain off the curd and cream. What remains, the serum, has a density that barely varies from cow to cow. Water shows up in it at once, and the size of the drop tells you how much was added. He also kept the older tool going. Milk stands for twelve hours in a tall graduated tube while the cream rises, and you read the cream as a percentage. Anyone could buy the tube, he noted, from almost any glass maker. Use the tube and the float together, he wrote, "the one acting as a corrective of the fallacies of the other."

Was Chalk Really Stirred Into Milk?

Hassall is the right person to ask. Between January 1851 and the end of 1854 he bought some 2,500 samples of food and drink around London. He examined each under a microscope, then with chemical tests. He published the results in The Lancet and named the sellers. For milk he bought from twenty-six dairies and cow-keepers.

Twelve were genuine, and two of those were short on cream. Eleven had been tampered with. The tampering "consisted, in all cases, of water," at ten to fifty percent. Then comes the line that matters most. Chalk, size, gum, sheep's brains and the other rumored additives were "in no case" detected. The list of things people feared tells you a lot about Victorian London. The list of things actually found had one item on it.

He was not surprised by the result. Thirty years earlier, Friedrich Accum had tested London milk for a living. The chalk notion, Accum wrote, "is unfounded." The smallest quantity "speedily separates, and falls to the bottom." He had clearly been asked about chalk often enough to sound tired of it. Water was another matter: "That a liberal quantity of water is often added to the London milk admits of no doubt."

Frank Leslie's artist watched a swill-milk cow being dissected at the 16th Street stables in New York, 1858. Eight men in top hats standing around a dead cow was, that year, investigative journalism. (Photo Credit: Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, via Library of Congress and Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
Frank Leslie's artist watched a swill-milk cow being dissected at the 16th Street stables in New York, 1858. Eight men in top hats standing around a dead cow was, that year, investigative journalism. (Photo Credit: Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, via Library of Congress and Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

There was a test regardless, and it is a tidy piece of chemistry. Boil a sample down and burn the residue to ash. Dissolve the ash in hydrochloric acid, filter it, and add a few drops of ammonium oxalate. Any calcium in the liquid drops out as a white solid, calcium oxalate. Milk always gives a slight haze, because milk contains calcium of its own. Chalk is calcium carbonate, and it gives "a tolerably abundant precipitate." Nobody in London seems to have needed the test.

None of this proves that no New York dairyman ever tried plaster or chalk. The American exposés alleged it, and a whitener would sink out of a milk can within the hour. It does mean the viral version has the fraud backwards. The exotic additives were the rumor; water was the business model.

How Did A Drop Of Iodine Expose Flour In Milk?

Water needed a cover, and flour was the cheap one. Starch thickens watery milk and gives back some body. Accum describes London dairies doing exactly this with arrowroot in 1820. They boiled it into skimmed milk and folded the paste into cream. The result had "a consistence and apparent richness." It was harmless to drink and hard to see.

It was not hard to find with the right bottle. Starch is built from long chains of sugar units. In one form, amylose, the chain coils up like a spring. Iodine molecules slip inside the coil, and the pair absorbs light in a way neither does alone. The whole mix turns an intense blue-black. With no starch present, iodine stays its usual orange-brown. Accum's test was a teaspoon of the suspect cream and a few drops of iodine in alcohol. Doctored cream "instantly produces with it a dark blue colour." Genuine cream picks up only "a faint yellow tinge."

The same reaction, used on apples: iodine turns starch blue-black, and the flesh that has already converted its starch to sugar stays pale. Milk hiding flour behaves like the bottom slice. (Photo Credit: Mezhenskyj, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
The same reaction, used on apples: iodine turns starch blue-black, and the flesh that has already converted its starch to sugar stays pale. Milk hiding flour behaves like the bottom slice. (Photo Credit: Mezhenskyj, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Milk itself is too white to show a color change, so the later version of the test worked on the clear part. Curdle the milk with a little vinegar and filter off the curd. Let the liquid cool and add the iodine. Blue means starch, flour, or boiled-up bran, barley or rice. A dairyman could beat a hydrometer with a jug of water and a skimmer. He could not beat a dropper bottle.

How Did Babcock's 1890 Test End The Watering Game?

By the 1880s the problem had moved from the city milk cart to the creamery gate. American farmers were paid for milk by weight. A farmer who added water or skimmed the cream got the same money as his honest neighbor and delivered less. The University of Wisconsin handed the problem to its farm chemist, Stephen Babcock. In 1890 he announced his test.

The test is direct to the point of brutality. Measure a standard weight of milk into a glass bottle with a long, thin neck. The neck is graduated from zero to eight percent. Add a precise dose of sulfuric acid, which dissolves every part of the milk except the fat. Warm the bottle and spin it in a hand-cranked centrifuge, and the freed fat floats up into the neck. Read the fat percentage straight off the graduations. Earlier methods could do the same, but they were slow and expensive. Babcock's took minutes, and a dairyman could run it himself.

A hand-crank Babcock centrifuge from the early 1900s. Acid dissolved everything but the fat; a few turns of the handle sent the fat up into a graduated neck to be read as a percentage. (Photo Credit: Science History Institute, CC BY 4.0)
A hand-crank Babcock centrifuge from the early 1900s. Acid dissolved everything but the fat; a few turns of the handle sent the fat up into a graduated neck to be read as a percentage. (Photo Credit: Science History Institute, CC BY 4.0)

The chemistry was the small part; the economics was the point. Once a creamery could measure fat cheaply, it could pay for fat, and it did. Water earned nothing, which had always been true of water. Skimming cost the farmer exactly what he had skimmed. Within a few years the test was also keeping records on individual cows, so herds could be bred for richer milk. The same bottle that caught the cheat improved the cow.

Why Do Food Frauds Still Beat Food Tests Today?

Lay the tests side by side and a pattern shows up. The hydrometer measured density, not quality. So the cheat went after density: skim, then water. Iodine measured starch, which is why starch stopped being used. Babcock measured the fat itself, and there was nothing cheap to add that would pass for fat. Every test measures a stand-in, and a clever fraud attacks the stand-in rather than the thing you care about.

Each test stood in for quality, and the cheats went after whatever the test could not tell apart.
Each test stood in for quality, and the cheats went after whatever the test could not tell apart.

The modern version played out in China in 2008. Labs estimate protein by measuring nitrogen, because protein is the main nitrogen-bearing ingredient in food. Melamine is an industrial chemical used to make plastics, and it is up to 66 percent nitrogen by mass. It was added to watered-down milk so the diluted product would pass the protein test. By late September that year, more than fifty thousand children had been treated for kidney problems, and at least four had died. The milk had been watered, exactly as in 1858. The whitener had been replaced by something that fooled the instrument instead of the eye. The same chemical had poisoned pets in the United States the year before.

So, how did early chemists catch watered-down swill milk? They stopped trusting any one measurement on its own. Hassall's answer in 1855 was two cheap tools used together, a cream tube and a float, with the serum test behind them. Today's answer is the same idea with better instruments. Added water is caught by the freezing point of milk, which creeps toward zero as water goes in. Melamine is caught by testing for melamine itself rather than for the nitrogen it imitates. The chalk never existed outside the rumor. The water was there the whole time, and a weighted glass float, read by someone who knew what cream does to it, was enough to find it.

References (click to expand)
  1. Food and Its Adulterations; Comprising the Reports of the Analytical Sanitary Commission of The Lancet for the Years 1851 to 1854 — Arthur Hill Hassall, 1855, Internet Archive
  2. A Treatise on Adulterations of Food, and Culinary Poisons — Friedrich Accum, 1820, Project Gutenberg
  3. The fight against food adulteration — Education in Chemistry, Royal Society of Chemistry
  4. Babcock milk testing bottle — National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution
  5. From Farm to Nuisance: Animal Agriculture and the Rise of Planning Regulation — Journal of Planning History (PMC)
  6. The Poison Squad (transcript) — PBS American Experience
  7. A method for testing the quality of milk using optical capillaries — Photonics Letters of Poland, 2009
  8. Focus on the supramolecular structure of milk fat in dairy products — Reproduction Nutrition Development, 2005
  9. Starch and Iodine — Chemistry LibreTexts
  10. Revisiting the melamine contamination event in China: implications for ethics in food technology — Trends in Food Science and Technology, 2009 (PMC)
  11. Melamine in dairy products: frequently asked questions — Centre for Food Safety, Hong Kong
  12. Freezing point osmometry of milk to determine the additional water content — Chemistry Central Journal, 2008 (PMC)
  13. Swill milk scandal — Wikipedia (supplementary)