If There's Water Right Under The City, Why Don't Skyscrapers Sink?

Table of Contents (click to expand)
Skyscrapers do not sink because a wide foundation spreads their weight thin, so the ground under a tower often carries little more than the soil dug out for the basement. Groundwater's real threat is not softening the mud but pushing a deep basement upward like a boat, which is why some buildings are anchored down instead of held up. Every tall building settles a little, and the engineer's job is to make that settling slow, small, and even, not to stop it.

Stand at the base of a skyscraper and look straight up. Above you sit tens of thousands of tons of steel, glass, and concrete. Dig down 30 meters (100 feet) or so under most cities and you hit water: not dry rock, but damp soil with water sitting in every gap.

So if the ground is soggy down there, why doesn't the whole building sink into it? Set a boot on wet mud and the boot sinks. A skyscraper weighs far more than a boot. It should sink faster.

It does not. And the reason is stranger than "the foundation goes deep." The water down there is a problem, but not the problem you would guess.

What Is Soil Actually Made Of?

We call it dirt, but to an engineer, soil is not a soft paste. It is a pile of solid grains stacked against each other, with water and air in the gaps between them.

Picture a jar full of marbles. The marbles touch, so press down on the top and the weight travels through them, from one to the next, all the way to the bottom. It is their touching that holds the load.

Real soil is a jar of marbles the size of sand and clay grains. The load travels through the grains, wherever they touch, not through the mud. Engineers call the water in the gaps pore water.

The strength of soil, the weight it can hold, comes almost entirely from how hard those grains grip each other. Press them together harder and the soil gets stronger. Loosen their grip and it gets weaker.

Up close, soil is a pile of solid grains stacked against each other. The load travels through the grains where they touch, not through the mud.
Up close, soil is a pile of solid grains stacked against each other. The load travels through the grains where they touch, not through the mud. (Photo Credit: Ypiyush22, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Now add the water, under pressure. An engineer named Karl Terzaghi worked this part out about a century ago, and it is called effective stress.

Go back to the marbles. The weight pressing down holds them together. But the water in the gaps pushes back, trying to spread them apart. The grip that actually holds the load is the downward press minus the upward water push. As a formula, it is short:

σ′ = σ − u

Here σ′ (said "sigma prime") is the grip between the grains, σ is the total weight pressing down, and u is the pore water pressure. Raise the water table and u goes up, so the grip goes down. The soil holds less, and you never touched the soil at all.

Bring the water table all the way up to the surface, and the soil under a shallow foundation can hold only about half as much weight as it did dry. This is why groundwater matters, and it has nothing to do with the mud being slippery.

The grip that holds a building up is the weight pressing down minus the water pressure pushing up. Raise the water table and the grip weakens, even though the soil itself never changes.
The grip that holds a building up is the weight pressing down minus the water pressure pushing up. Raise the water table and the grip weakens, even though the soil itself never changes.

How Hard Does A Skyscraper Press On The Ground?

The second surprise is that a skyscraper does not press down nearly as hard as you think.

Weight is not the same as pressure. A stiletto heel dents a wooden floor that a heavy elephant leaves untouched, because the heel puts a big weight on a tiny patch. A foundation does the opposite. It spreads a giant weight over a giant patch.

Take the Empire State Building. It weighs about 365,000 tons, and it sits on a base of about 2 acres. Spread that weight over that base and the pressure comes out to only about twice the pressure in your car's tires. That is also the weight of a soil layer about 23 meters (75 feet) deep. In other words, the building presses on the ground about as hard as the dirt that used to be there.

Spread over its footprint, the Empire State Building presses on the ground about as hard as two car tires, and about as hard as the soil that was there before it.
Spread over its footprint, the Empire State Building presses on the ground about as hard as two car tires, and about as hard as the soil that was there before it.

That last point hides a clever trick. Dig a hole for a basement and you carry away thousands of tons of soil that used to press on the ground below. Build the tower in the hole and you put that weight back. If the tower weighs about the same as the soil you removed, the ground below barely notices the swap. Engineers call this a floating foundation. The building sits in its hole like a boat sits in water.

Mexico City is the proving ground. It sits on the soft clay of a drained lake, some of the worst building ground on Earth. The Torre Latinoamericana rests on hundreds of long concrete shafts, called piles, driven deep into that lakebed, and it is built to float on it. It stood through major quakes in 1957 and 1985, while sturdier-looking buildings around it fell. Floating, it turns out, is a feature.

Do Skyscrapers Really Reach Down To Bedrock?

Ask most people how a skyscraper stays up and they will say it stands on piles that reach all the way down to solid rock. That is the neat answer, and it is often wrong.

A pile can hold a building up in two ways. It can rest its tip on hard rock, which engineers call end bearing. Or the soil packed along its whole length can hold it by friction, like a tent peg held by the dirt around it. Engineers call that skin friction, and it does most of the work.

The tallest building on Earth proves it. The Burj Khalifa stands on 192 concrete piles that reach roughly 50 meters down. They hold the tower up mainly through skin friction, not by resting on rock. The world's tallest tower is held in place by the soil, like a wildly expensive tent peg.

The Burj Khalifa, the tallest building in the world, is held up mostly by friction between the soil and its piles. It never reaches solid rock.
The Burj Khalifa, the tallest building in the world, is held up mostly by friction between the soil and its piles. It never reaches solid rock. (Photo Credit: Eric Chamchoum, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

Why A Deep Basement Tries To Float Upward

Now for the plot the water was hiding. Groundwater's biggest threat to a tall building is not that it weakens the mud. It is that it tries to push the building up out of the ground.

A deep basement below the water table is a sealed box sitting in water, and anything sitting in water gets pushed up. This is the same push that floats a boat, or an ice cube in your drink. Archimedes wrote it down thousands of years ago. The water does not care that the box is full of concrete and parking spaces. It pushes up all the same.

For a big empty basement, that upward push can be enormous. Sometimes it beats the weight of the building above, and then engineers add tension piles, anchors that hold the structure down. Sometimes the engineering problem is not holding a skyscraper up. It is stopping it from floating away. A half-built basement, before the heavy tower is added on top, is the most nervous moment of all.

Below the water table, a basement behaves like a boat hull. If the upward push beats the building's weight, anchors have to hold it down.
Below the water table, a basement behaves like a boat hull. If the upward push beats the building's weight, anchors have to hold it down.

What Happens When A Building Settles Unevenly?

The failures teach the rules better than the successes do. The most famous one has been leaning for 800 years.

The Leaning Tower of Pisa did not lean on purpose. It stands on weak, soft layers of clay and silt, and its foundation was too shallow for such poor ground. One side settled more than the other, and the tower tipped. By the 1990s it was close to falling over.

The fix is beautifully backwards. Instead of jacking the leaning side up, engineers gently dug soil out from under the high side, so the tall side could settle and catch up with the low side. The tower straightened by about 45 centimeters (18 inches). They did not make it straight. They made it safe, and left the lean the tourists came for.

Pisa leans because a shallow foundation sat on soft, uneven clay. Engineers straightened it by carefully removing soil from under the high side.
Pisa leans because a shallow foundation sat on soft, uneven clay. Engineers straightened it by carefully removing soil from under the high side. (Photo Credit: MHoser, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

The modern version played out under people's homes. San Francisco's Millennium Tower is a 58-story luxury high-rise that opened in 2009. Its original piles relied on skin friction in dense sand, not on bedrock. The design expected a few inches of settling. Instead the building settled about 14 inches (36 centimeters) and began to tilt.

The repair was more piles. Crews installed 18 new piles around the building's edge, this time driven all the way to bedrock, and shifted part of the tower's weight onto them. By 2023 the settling had stopped. It is a costly reminder of what happens when a foundation trusts the soil more than the soil has earned.

San Francisco's Millennium Tower settled far more than its designers expected. The cure was a ring of new piles driven down to bedrock.
San Francisco's Millennium Tower settled far more than its designers expected. The cure was a ring of new piles driven down to bedrock. (Photo Credit: Hydrogen Iodide, Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

How Can Groundwater Sink A Whole City?

There is a bigger version of the story, where the ground itself drops out from under a whole city.

It happens when a city pumps too much water out of the soil beneath it. Remember effective stress. Take the pore water away and the grains have to carry more of the load themselves, so they pack down tighter, often in a way that cannot be undone. The land above sinks.

Mexico City is the extreme case. It is draining the same soft lakebed its towers float on. Parts of the city now sink about 35 centimeters (14 inches) every year, and over the last century it has dropped several meters. Here the lesson flips. The buildings are not settling into the ground. The ground is falling away from the buildings. Towers on piles can seem to rise slowly out of the pavement around them.

Mexico City spreads across a drained lakebed. Pumping water from the clay below it drops the ground about 35 centimeters (14 inches) a year in places.
Mexico City spreads across a drained lakebed. Pumping water from the clay below it drops the ground about 35 centimeters (14 inches) a year in places. (Photo Credit: Jonathan Salvador, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

A skyscraper does not sink because it is smart about weight. A wide foundation spreads the load thin, so the ground often carries little more than the soil that was dug away to make room for it. Deep piles hand that load to stronger soil below, mostly by friction, sometimes by reaching rock. And where water tries to push the building out of the ground, anchors hold it down. The soggy soil the question worried about comes down to one idea: the grip between grains.

Every one of these buildings is settling right now, including the good ones. Soil packs down slowly, and clay can keep settling for decades. The engineer's goal is not to stop that. It is to make the movement slow, small, and even, so the whole building drifts down together by an amount decided in advance. A tower that settles a few inches evenly is fine. One that settles unevenly, like Pisa or the Millennium Tower, is the one that makes the news.

So the water under the city was never the enemy. The ancient Romans figured out most of the art of not sinking with far cruder tools than ours. A skyscraper is not a building fighting the ground. It is a building that made peace with it, one grain at a time.

References (click to expand)
  1. Effective stress and Terzaghi's principle — Wikipedia
  2. The Effect of the Water Table on the Bearing Capacity of a Shallow Foundation — Applied Sciences 12(13):6571, MDPI
  3. Poulos & Bunce, Foundation Design for the Burj Dubai — ICCHGE / Missouri S&T
  4. Torre Latinoamericana: Seismic Engineering in Mexico — Institution of Civil Engineers (ICE)
  5. Methods of resisting hydrostatic uplift in substructures — Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology (ScienceDirect)
  6. Burland, The Stabilisation of the Leaning Tower of Pisa — Ingenia, Royal Academy of Engineering
  7. Groundwater Pumping Is Causing Mexico City to Sink — Eos (AGU)
  8. Over a Century of Sinking in Mexico City — Chaussard et al., Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth (2021)
  9. Groundwater-related subsidence — Wikipedia
  10. Land Subsidence — USGS Water Resources
  11. Millennium Tower, San Francisco — Simpson Gumpertz & Heger (SGH)
  12. After 15 Years, Settlement Arrested at San Francisco's Millennium Tower — Engineering News-Record