How Do You Extract Energy From A Black Hole Using A Device That Never Spins?

Table of Contents (click to expand)

In 2026, physicists at CUNY built a ring of electronic parts that never moves, retuned those parts in a sequence that raced around the ring, and found that radio waves passing through came out 7.8 decibels stronger, about six times the power, because the waves reacted as if the ring were spinning. That copies a trick Roger Penrose proposed in 1969: a spinning black hole drags space around so hard that if you split an object in two just outside its horizon, one half falls in and the other escapes with more energy than the whole thing started with. Repeat it enough and a black hole gives up as much as 29% of its energy before it runs out of spin.

Picture a black hole doing its most famous trick: pulling everything in, giving nothing back. That is the reputation. It is not the whole story.

In July 2026, a team at CUNY, the City University of New York, switched on a ring-shaped circuit. Nothing in it moved. No motor, no spinning disk, not even a fan. Radio waves went in, and they came out stronger, the team reported. The ring had copied the one thing a spinning black hole can do that nothing else can: hand back more energy than it received.

To see why that is strange, you first need to see what a spinning black hole does to the space around it.

What Does A Spinning Black Hole Do To The Space Around It?

A black hole is a region where gravity has crushed matter so tight that not even light can climb back out past a boundary called the event horizon. That much is famous. What a spinning black hole does to the space just outside that boundary is less famous, and stranger.

Dip a spoon into a jar of honey and twirl it. The honey right next to the spoon gets dragged around with it. A little further out, the honey drags less. Further out still, it barely moves. Now swap the spoon for a spinning black hole and the honey for space itself. That is not a loose metaphor. A spinning mass really does drag the fabric of space around with it, and a satellite experiment has measured that drag around Earth, a body that spins slowly by black hole standards. Physicists call this frame dragging.

Around a spinning black hole, the drag turns extreme. Close enough in, space gets dragged around faster than light itself moves. That region, just outside the event horizon, is the ergosphere. Everything inside it, light included, is forced to orbit in the direction of the spin. Nothing can sit still there. It is the honey nearest the spoon.

Here is the one detail the rest of this article rests on. The ergosphere is not the event horizon. You can fall into it and still climb back out. The honey drags you around, but it does not hold you. That one fact, that the ergosphere lets you leave, is what makes stealing energy from it possible at all.

The ergosphere (outer boundary) sits outside the event horizon of a spinning black hole. Inside it, space itself is dragged around faster than light, but escape is still possible, unlike past the horizon.
The ergosphere (outer boundary) sits outside the event horizon of a spinning black hole. Inside it, space itself is dragged around faster than light, but escape is still possible, unlike past the horizon. (Photo Credit: Perhelion, based on earlier work by MesserWoland / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

How Does A Black Hole Hand Back Energy?

Physicists have known how, on paper, since 1969. That year Roger Penrose proposed a thought experiment. Drop an object into the ergosphere of a spinning black hole and have it split into two pieces while it is still inside. Arrange the split right, and one piece falls through the event horizon while the other shoots back out. Check the energy books, and the escaping piece carries more energy than the original object had. The black hole pays the difference.

How can a piece of something carry more energy than the whole? Inside the ergosphere, and only there, an object can carry negative energy, as measured by someone watching from far away. That sounds like nonsense, but energy only makes sense relative to something else, and deep in the ergosphere the drag on space is so violent that the usual rules bend. Nothing with negative energy can escape on its own; it has to fall into the black hole. So split a falling object in two, let one piece carry the negative energy inward, and the other piece, to balance the books, is left holding more than the pair started with. That piece is free to leave.

Nobody breaks the rule that energy is conserved. The bonus comes straight out of the black hole's spin, and the spin drops by that much. Back at the honey jar: anything you drop in gets dragged along, and if it is flung back out moving faster than it went in, the hand on the spoon felt the extra drag. A spinning black hole is, in this sense, a huge, patient energy reserve, and the Penrose process is the only known way to tap it directly.

Do this enough times, and a black hole spinning as fast as physics allows can give up 29% of its total mass-energy. After that, the black hole is still there. It has simply run out of spin to give. Somewhere, a physicist sat down and did that arithmetic, and confirmed you can get more out than you put in, as long as the thing you rob is a black hole and not your car battery.

An object splits inside the ergosphere. One half carries negative energy into the black hole. The other escapes carrying more energy than the original object had, paid for by the black hole's spin.
An object splits inside the ergosphere. One half carries negative energy into the black hole. The other escapes carrying more energy than the original object had, paid for by the black hole's spin.

Does The Same Trick Work On Waves?

It does, and it does not even need a black hole. In 1971, the Soviet physicist Yakov Zel'dovich studied a wave bouncing off a spinning object that absorbs some of it. Normally the wave loses energy to the object. But Zel'dovich showed that once the object spins faster than the wave's own twisting pattern turns around it, the sign flips: the wave stops losing energy to the object and starts taking energy from it. Physicists call this superradiance, and the spin rate where it switches on is the Zel'dovich threshold. A black hole's ergosphere runs the same rule. It drags space hard enough to flip the sign for anything twisted the right way that wanders in.

Two experiments caught this happening before CUNY ever built its ring. In 2020, a team spun a foam disc fast and fired twisted sound waves at it. Once the disc passed the Zel'dovich threshold, the sound came back stronger than it went in, the first experimental test of the effect, done with ordinary sound instead of light. In 2024, the idea moved to electromagnetic waves. Researchers wrapped a coil around a small aluminum cylinder and spun it inside an oscillating magnetic field. Below the threshold, the spinning metal absorbed energy from the field. Past the threshold, the cylinder's electrical resistance flipped negative: it was now adding power to the circuit instead of draining it, just as Zel'dovich predicted. A block of spinning metal, running a black hole's oldest trick on a lab bench.

Both experiments needed something to physically spin, and spin fast. That is where CUNY's ring breaks the pattern.

How Did CUNY Fake Spin Without Spinning Anything?

Here is the part that sounds impossible. The CUNY device never spins. Not slowly, not fast, not at all. It is a ring of small electronic parts, called resonators, bolted to a bench. Nothing in it has ever moved a millimeter.

Instead, the team retuned each resonator in turn, one after another around the ring, on a tight schedule. Think of the chase lights on a theater marquee: not one bulb moves, yet the glow runs around the sign. No resonator moved either, but the pattern of retuning did, racing around the loop. An incoming radio wave cannot tell the difference. All a wave can sense is how its surroundings change over time and position, not whether an object physically moved to cause the change. So the wave reacts as if the ring were truly spinning.

The physicists named this synthetic rotation: a fake spin. Because the thing "spinning" is a pattern of retuning, not an object, it is free to run around the ring faster than light. That breaks no law of physics. Nothing with mass, and no information, travels that fast, only the timing of a signal that is already there. Push the fake spin past the Zel'dovich threshold and the ring stops absorbing radio waves and starts handing them back stronger.

How much stronger? The team measured 7.8 decibels. A decibel is not a normal unit like a meter or a kilogram. It is a ratio, and every 10 decibels means ten times the power, so 7.8 decibels works out to about six times. The wave left the ring carrying six times the power it walked in with. That is not a rounding error, and it came from a device with a permanent alibi for never having moved.

A ring of resonators, none of them moving, retuned in sequence so the pattern races around the loop, faking spin fast enough to send an incoming wave out stronger.
A ring of resonators, none of them moving, retuned in sequence so the pattern races around the loop, faking spin fast enough to send an incoming wave out stronger.

Is This Actually Free Energy?

No, and this needs saying directly, because perpetual-motion inventors have chased "more out than in, with nothing moving" since the 1700s.

The resonators still need power to be retuned. The marquee has an electric bill too, even though the only thing "moving" is which bulb is lit. Nothing here produces more energy than went into the whole system, resonators and switching circuits included. The experiment does not reveal a new source of energy. It reveals a new route: energy already riding a wave turns into more wave, through the same loophole Zel'dovich spotted decades ago, open to anything, spinning or fake-spinning, that crosses his threshold.

So, how do you extract energy from a black hole with a device that never spins? A spinning black hole drags space around it, honey around a spoon, so hard that just outside its event horizon nothing can sit still and negative energy becomes possible. Split something in two there, and one half falls in while the other escapes with a bonus paid for by the black hole's spin. Zel'dovich showed the same bonus goes to ordinary waves bouncing off anything that spins fast enough, no event horizon required.

CUNY's physicists exploited that last part. A wave does not need a real spinning object. It only needs to be fooled into sensing one. Retune a ring of resonators in a traveling, timed sequence, and the ring crosses the Zel'dovich threshold without moving. Out the other side comes a radio wave carrying six times the power of the one that went in.

No black hole was harmed, or even located, in making that result happen. Somewhere out there, a real one keeps spinning anyway, dragging space around itself hard enough to make this whole trick possible, and slowly paying the price in stolen spin.

References (click to expand)
  1. Physicists recreate black hole energy extraction in the lab — ScienceDaily
  2. A Black Hole Theory Comes to Life in the Lab — CUNY Advanced Science Research Center
  3. Synthetic rotation brings black hole energy theory into lab, amplifying waves — Phys.org
  4. Observation of Floquet rotational super-radiance — Nature (2026)
  5. Cromb, M., Gibson, G.M., Toninelli, E., Padgett, M.J., Wright, E.M. & Faccio, D. (2020). "Amplification of waves from a rotating body." Nature Physics, 16, 1069–1073.
  6. Amplification of electromagnetic fields by a rotating body — PMC / NCBI Bookshelf
  7. Rotating cylinder amplifies electromagnetic fields — Physics World
  8. Gravity Probe B: Frame Dragging — Stanford / NASA
  9. Astronomy 130: Physical Properties and Types of Black Holes — Penn State University