Why Don't Wind Turbines Have Six Or Eight Blades To Catch More Wind?

Table of Contents (click to expand)
A wind turbine blade is a wing, not a sail, and a wing needs clean air, so every extra blade is flying through air the one ahead of it has already used. No rotor can take more than about 59 percent of the wind's energy, and the best three-blade rotors already get most of the way there, so more blades buy almost nothing. Fewer blades spin faster and make the gearbox lighter and the power cheaper, and two blades would be cheapest of all, but a two-blade rotor shakes its tower twice every turn, so three became the compromise the whole industry copied from Danish designs in the 1970s.

Drive past a wind farm and count. Every machine carries three blades, never four, never six. The obvious question follows: if the job is to catch wind, why not bolt on more blades and catch more of it? A sail with twice the cloth catches twice the wind, and a rotor with twice the blades should do the same.

It is a sensible guess, and it fails three separate ways. A turbine blade does not catch wind at all. The wind refuses to hand over most of its energy, whatever you put in front of it. And the number three was settled partly by a shake, partly by cost, and partly by a few Danish workshops in the 1970s. To see why, start with what a blade does up there.

Why Doesn't A Wind Turbine Catch The Wind Like A Sail?

Hold your hand flat out of a car window and tilt it a little. The air lifts it, because your hand is working as a wing. Air moving over the tilted top surface ends up at lower pressure than the air underneath, and that difference pushes the hand up. A turbine blade is that hand, stretched to the length of a football field and set spinning.

The blades work like an airplane wing. The pressure difference across a moving blade's two sides creates both lift and drag, and lift is the stronger of the two, so the rotor spins. Lift pulls the blade round; the wind does not push it.

One twist decides everything that follows. A blade tip moves far faster than the wind, six to nine times faster on a large turbine. Most of the air a blade meets, then, is air it slices into through its own motion, with the wind adding a slant. The blade is a wing flying through a breeze it makes for itself, in a circle, like a helicopter rotor. A sail wants to block air. A wing wants clean air. That one difference is the whole case against extra blades.

A blade section seen from the tip. The air it meets is mostly its own motion plus a slant of wind. Lift acts at right angles to that apparent wind, and the part of the lift pointing along the blade's travel is what turns the rotor.
A blade section seen from the tip. The air it meets is mostly its own motion plus a slant of wind. Lift acts at right angles to that apparent wind, and the part of the lift pointing along the blade's travel is what turns the rotor.

How Much Of The Wind's Energy Can A Turbine Take?

The power in a patch of wind grows with the cube of its speed, so doubling the wind gives eight times the power. A turbine can never take all of it. To pull energy out of the air, the rotor has to slow the air down. Slowed air has to spread out, because the same amount of air still has to get past. Slow it to a standstill and nothing flows through at all; the rotor would be a wall. The theory says to slow the air at the rotor to two thirds of its speed, so that the wake far behind drifts at one third. At that point the rotor captures about 59 percent of the wind's energy. Engineers call this the Betz limit, and it is a ceiling.

The ceiling matters for blade count because the best rotors are already close to it. Modern large turbines capture about four fifths of the Betz figure. The same ceiling came up when we asked whether we could harness energy from tornadoes. The best three-blade rotors already sit within a few points of the best that any number of blades could manage. More blades are chasing a gap that is almost closed.

Left: a rotor can only take energy by slowing the air, and slowed air spreads out. Right: the share captured peaks at 59.3% when the wake is slowed to a third of the wind speed. Slow it more and the air stops flowing through.
Left: a rotor can only take energy by slowing the air, and slowed air spreads out. Right: the share captured peaks at 59.3% when the wake is slowed to a third of the wind speed. Slow it more and the air stops flowing through.

What Is The Best Number Of Blades On A Wind Turbine?

Engineers measure how much of the rotor's circle is filled with blade and call it solidity. Low solidity means a fast rotor with little twisting force; high solidity means a slow rotor with a lot of it. An old American farm windmill, its wheel packed with curved sails, is all solidity. It turns slowly and pulls hard, which is what you want for hauling water up a well pipe. It is a poor way to make electricity, because the generator behind a rotor wants speed.

Pack more blades into the same circle and each one gets a smaller share of the clean air. The rotor still takes the same energy from the wind, so it turns more slowly to do it. Read the other way round, a rotor with fewer blades has to spin faster to make its power.

A wind-tunnel test put this to the proof with one small rotor fitted first with three blades, then with five. Both took the same share of the wind's power. The three-blade rotor simply spun faster to do it. The five blades did help the small machine start turning in light wind, which is why some tiny rooftop turbines carry extra blades. For a big machine feeding the grid, the extra blades buy almost nothing in energy and cost a blade each.

An Aermotor farm windmill at the USDA research station in Bushland, Texas. Dozens of sails, high solidity, lots of twisting force, and no interest in going fast: the right design for a water pump and the wrong one for a generator. (Photo Credit: Paul Gipe, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
An Aermotor farm windmill at the USDA research station in Bushland, Texas. Dozens of sails, high solidity, lots of twisting force, and no interest in going fast: the right design for a water pump and the wrong one for a generator. (Photo Credit: Paul Gipe, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Why Are Fewer, Faster Blades Cheaper (Until The Noise Starts)?

Behind the hub sits either a gearbox or a large generator that the rotor turns directly. Both get lighter when the rotor spins faster. The same power at higher speed means less twisting force to carry, and twisting force is what makes gearboxes heavy. Let the tips run a quarter faster, one design exercise found, and the gearbox comes out about a third lighter and a third cheaper, which trims the lifetime cost of the electricity by one to nine percent. Fewer blades push the design the same way, since a two- or three-blade rotor has to run faster than a five-blade one.

So why not spin faster still? Noise. Onshore turbines keep their tip speeds to about 80 meters per second, which is roughly 290 km/h (180 mph) at the tip. That is well short of the speed of sound, so this is not the drag wall that caps airliners. It is the hiss of air leaving the back edge of the blade. When researchers aimed more than a hundred microphones at a working turbine, this hiss was the dominant sound, and its level rose with the fifth power of the local air speed.

Fifth power is brutal. Let the tips run a quarter faster and the noise energy triples. Double the tip speed and it rises 32-fold. Onshore, the neighbors set the tip speed, and the tip speed sets how few blades you can get away with.

Trailing-edge noise energy against blade tip speed, scaled from the measured fifth-power law. The shaded band is the usual onshore cap. Going from 80 to 100 m/s triples the noise energy, about 5 decibels.
Trailing-edge noise energy against blade tip speed, scaled from the measured fifth-power law. The shaded band is the usual onshore cap. Going from 80 to 100 m/s triples the noise energy, about 5 decibels.

Why Don't Wind Turbines Have Two Blades?

If fewer is cheaper, two should beat three. The rotor loses a third of its blades, and that could cut the cost of the rotor by a third. Yet almost every big turbine has three. The reason is a shake, and it comes in two flavors.

First, a two-blade rotor is not the same shape from every angle. Horizontal, it spans the whole diameter; vertical, it spans nothing sideways. Wind is stronger higher up, so the blades meet different wind every half-turn, and the hub feels an extra bending load twice per turn. Add the loads from turning the whole machine to face the wind while the blades lie flat, and the blade roots, hub and tower all wear out faster. A three-blade rotor looks and loads the same whichever way it points, so it is spared most of that.

Second, the gyroscope. Spin a bicycle wheel, hold the axle, and try to turn it: it twists back at you. A two-blade rotor turning to track the wind does the same. The fix engineers keep returning to is a teetering hub, a hinge that lets the whole rotor rock like a seesaw and shed the uneven loads. In one 20 MW two-blade design, tuned control software cut the tower's fatigue load from more than three times the three-blade figure to about a third more, and a teetering hub trimmed it further. A two-blade rotor also gives up a few percent of its annual energy unless its blades are made wider to compensate.

Two-blade machines were the mainstream once. NASA's first experimental turbine went up on its tower in Ohio in 1975 with two blades, each weighing about a ton, and its bigger successors kept the layout. Denmark went the other way. Johannes Juul, an engineer at a Danish utility, had built a three-bladed machine at Gedser that ran from 1959 to 1967. When the oil shocks of the 1970s revived interest in wind, small Danish makers copied his recipe: three blades, upwind, simple. By 1998 a review of the industry named the three-bladed, horizontal-axis machine as the most used design worldwide.

Two blades have not died. Offshore, where nobody lives next door and the tips can run faster, engineers still call two versus three an open question, with 20 MW two-blade designs on paper.

NASA's 200 kW Mod-0A two-bladed turbine on Block Island, Rhode Island, in 1979. Two blades were the American way in the 1970s. (Photo Credit: NASA Glenn Research Center, image GRC-1979-C-02443, public domain)
NASA's 200 kW Mod-0A two-bladed turbine on Block Island, Rhode Island, in 1979. Two blades were the American way in the 1970s. (Photo Credit: NASA Glenn Research Center, image GRC-1979-C-02443, public domain)

So, Why Do Wind Turbines Have Three Blades?

Stack the pieces. A blade is a wing, so it wants clean air, and each extra blade takes some of that away. The Betz ceiling means the best rotors already capture about four fifths of what any rotor could. Fewer blades spin faster, and faster means a lighter gearbox and cheaper power, right up to the point where the neighbors can hear the tips. Two blades would be cheaper still. But a two-blade rotor shakes its tower twice a turn and fights its own gyroscope whenever it turns to face the wind. Three is the smallest number that looks and loads the same from every angle.

Then history froze it. Denmark's three-blade recipe worked, onshore buyers cared about noise, and by the 1990s it was the default worldwide. None of this makes three the most efficient number. The wind tunnel put three and five blades at the same share of the wind's power; three just gets there at lower cost.

The preserved rotor of Johannes Juul's Gedser turbine, the three-bladed 200 kW machine that ran from 1959 to 1967 and became the template for the Danish wind industry. (Photo Credit: Villy Fink Isaksen, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
The preserved rotor of Johannes Juul's Gedser turbine, the three-bladed 200 kW machine that ran from 1959 to 1967 and became the template for the Danish wind industry. (Photo Credit: Villy Fink Isaksen, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

The industry did add more blade over the past quarter of a century. It added it to the length. Since the late 1990s the area swept by a new US turbine has grown nearly eightfold, and the blade count has stayed at three the entire time.

References (click to expand)
  1. How Do Wind Turbines Work? — U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy
  2. Wind Turbines: the Bigger, the Better — U.S. Department of Energy
  3. Gaertner et al. Definition of the IEA 15-Megawatt Offshore Reference Wind Turbine. NREL/TP-5000-75698 (2020) — OSTI
  4. Vedovelli, Eltayesh, Natili, Castellani. Experimental and Numerical Investigation of the Effect of Blades Number on the Dynamic Response of a Small Horizontal-Axis Wind Turbine. Energies 15, 9134 (2022)
  5. Lentink et al. Nature's Wind Turbines: The Measured Aerodynamic Efficiency of Spinning Seeds Approaches Theoretical Limits. Biomimetics (2022) — PMC
  6. Betz's law — Wikipedia (supplementary)
  7. Wind Energy Technology: What works & what doesn't — University of Hawaii (course slides)
  8. Civati, Sartori, Croce. Design of a two-bladed 10 MW rotor with teetering hub. J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1037, 042007 (2018)
  9. Dykes et al. Effect of Tip-Speed Constraints on the Optimized Design of a Wind Turbine. NREL/TP-5000-61726 (2014) — OSTI
  10. Oerlemans, Sijtsma, Méndez López. Location and quantification of noise sources on a wind turbine. Journal of Sound and Vibration 299, 869–883 (2007)
  11. Anstock, Schütt, Schorbach. Design of a two-bladed counterpart to the three-bladed INNWIND 20 MW offshore reference wind turbine. Wind Energy Science preprint wes-2024-121 (2024)
  12. Puthoff. Fabrication and Assembly of the ERDA/NASA 100-Kilowatt Experimental Wind Turbine. NASA TM X-3390 (1976) — NTRS
  13. Andersen, P. D. Review of Historical and Modern Utilization of Wind Power. Risø National Laboratory (1998) — DTU Orbit
  14. Gedser wind turbine — Wikipedia (supplementary)