Why Don't We Use X-Rays Or Ultraviolet Light For Wireless Communication?

Table of Contents (click to expand)

Radio won the wireless job because the data a wave can carry depends on how wide a slice of spectrum you use and how clean the signal is, not on how short each wave is. X-rays and the shortest ultraviolet are soaked up by air within meters, cast hard shadows instead of bending around walls, and carry enough energy to knock electrons out of the atoms in your body, so filling a city with them would be both useless and dangerous. Engineers do use short waves where the path is clear: infrared light in fiber cables and between spacecraft, a sliver of ultraviolet for short links, and one X-ray transmitter tested on the space station.

Here is an argument that sounds airtight. A Wi-Fi signal wiggles a few billion times every second. An X-ray wiggles about a billion times faster. If every wiggle can carry a bit of information, an X-ray should move a billion times more data. Yet every wireless signal that reaches your pocket sits at the long end of the spectrum.

The airtight argument fails in three separate ways, which is a lot for one sentence. One failure is about information, one about air, and one about what an X-ray does to the atoms it meets. To see all three, you need the spectrum laid out in front of you.

What Is The Electromagnetic Spectrum, And How Do Radio Waves Differ From X-Rays?

Radio, the glow of a stove element, sunlight and the beam in a dentist's X-ray machine are the same thing. Each is an electromagnetic wave, a ripple in electric and magnetic fields. It needs no air or water to travel, and it crosses empty space at the speed of light. The only thing that changes along the spectrum is the length of each ripple.

NASA's tour of the spectrum lays out the order. Radio waves are the longest, from the length of a football to bigger than Earth. Then come microwaves, infrared, visible light, ultraviolet, X-rays and gamma rays. An X-ray is shorter than 3 nanometers, so short that some are no bigger than an atom. Shorter waves mean more waves per second, so frequency climbs in the same order.

Short wave, high frequency and high energy travel together. Light arrives in packets called photons. An X-ray photon packs far more energy than a radio one. A radio photon is a feather; an X-ray photon is a dart. That pairing of short and energetic is the one idea the rest of this article rests on. Radio waves are not sound, by the way; they are light your eyes cannot see.

The spectrum from radio to gamma rays. Wavelength shrinks from buildings to atomic nuclei left to right, and only two narrow windows get through Earth's atmosphere. (Photo Credit: Inductiveload / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
The spectrum from radio to gamma rays. Wavelength shrinks from buildings to atomic nuclei left to right, and only two narrow windows get through Earth's atmosphere. (Photo Credit: Inductiveload / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

Do Shorter Waves Really Carry More Data?

Information rides on change. To send a bit, you alter the wave in a way the receiver can notice: a touch louder, a touch quieter, a small shift in timing. What matters is how many of those changes per second the channel allows. That depends on bandwidth, the width of the slice of spectrum you may use. It does not depend on the length of each wave.

Claude Shannon proved the ceiling. Engineering courses still teach his formula as the limit for any channel:

C = B × log2(1 + S/N).

Here C is the capacity in bits per second and B is the bandwidth in hertz. S/N is how much stronger the signal is than the background noise. Wavelength is not in it. Try a channel 20 MHz wide with a signal a thousand times stronger than the noise:

  1. Add one to the signal-to-noise ratio and take the base-two logarithm. For a thousand, that comes to just under ten.
  2. Multiply by the bandwidth. Ten times 20 million is about 200 million bits per second.

Double the bandwidth and the rate doubles. Shorten the wave and nothing happens.

The grain of truth is that a higher carrier frequency leaves room for a wider slice. The wide slice carries the bits; the short wave only buys the room. If that room came with three other problems, you would stay in the radio band, and it does.

Capacity climbs with bandwidth and with a cleaner signal. The wavelength of the carrier never enters the formula.
Capacity climbs with bandwidth and with a cleaner signal. The wavelength of the carrier never enters the formula.

Why Does Air Swallow Ultraviolet And X-Rays?

The first problem is the air. Sunlight carries the whole spectrum, and the atmosphere is a filter. Ozone and ordinary oxygen absorb all of the shortest ultraviolet, called UVC, and most of the next band, UVB. The ozone layer doing that work sits roughly 15 to 40 kilometers up. Ultraviolet fired along the ground meets the same gas.

X-rays fare worse, and how much worse depends on their energy. Physicists grade X-rays in kiloelectronvolts, written keV. A bigger number means a harder, more penetrating ray. Run the absorption tables for dry air through the usual decay formula and the picture is stark. A soft 1 keV X-ray dies within a few millimeters. A 20 keV X-ray travels better. Nine in ten survive the first meter, but only four in ten cross a 10-meter room.

X-rays above 30 keV can cross a few meters of air, which is why medical machines work. But the air column above you stops almost all of them arriving from space. That is why X-ray telescopes ride satellites instead of mountaintops.

Share of an X-ray beam still travelling after a given distance through sea-level air, computed from NIST's attenuation coefficients. The softer the ray, the sooner the air wins.
Share of an X-ray beam still travelling after a given distance through sea-level air, computed from NIST's attenuation coefficients. The softer the ray, the sooner the air wins.
How much of each wavelength the atmosphere blocks. Gamma rays, X-rays and ultraviolet are stopped high up; visible light and a broad radio window get through. (Photo Credit: NASA, SVG by Mysid / Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
How much of each wavelength the atmosphere blocks. Gamma rays, X-rays and ultraviolet are stopped high up; visible light and a broad radio window get through. (Photo Credit: NASA, SVG by Mysid / Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

Why Can't X-Rays Or UV Bend Around A Wall Like Wi-Fi Does?

The second problem waits at the first doorway. Waves bend around obstacles, an effect called diffraction. How much they bend depends on how the wavelength compares with the gap. When the gap is close to the wavelength, the wave fans out on the far side. When the gap dwarfs the wavelength, the wave carries straight on and leaves a crisp shadow.

A Wi-Fi signal at 2.4 gigahertz is 12.5 centimeters long. A doorway is only a few times wider. So the wave spills around furniture and leaks into the next room. It is why your router works through walls at all. An X-ray is about a billion times shorter. To it, a doorway is a canyon, and it goes straight through the opening and nowhere else, the way a bullet would.

Radio's superpower is not reaching you in a straight line. It is reaching you when there is no straight line. Ultraviolet, shorter than visible light, is just as happy as light to stop at a wall.

A 12.5 cm radio wave fans out past a doorway and fills the room; a nanometer X-ray goes straight through the gap and leaves everything else in shadow. Schematic, not to scale.
A 12.5 cm radio wave fans out past a doorway and fills the room; a nanometer X-ray goes straight through the gap and leaves everything else in shadow. Schematic, not to scale.

What Happens If You Come In Contact With X-Rays Or Gamma Rays?

The third problem is the one the dentist's lead apron is about. Radio waves, microwaves and visible light are non-ionizing. They have enough energy to make the atoms in a molecule vibrate, but not enough to pull electrons off them. X-rays and gamma rays carry so much energy per photon that they knock electrons out of atoms. That damages tissue and DNA. It is why cell towers are safe to live near, and why radiation shields are made of lead.

A phone network built on X-rays would bathe every street in ionizing radiation all day. No city would accept that dose for a faster download. Ultraviolet is gentler but not harmless. The UVC lamps used to disinfect rooms give off light that damages DNA. It reddens skin like a sunburn and inflames the eye. Not a thing you want streaming from the ceiling.

Then there is the transmitter. The X-ray tube in a hospital makes its rays by slamming electrons into a metal target. When they hit, about 99% of their energy becomes heat and about 1% becomes X-rays. An X-ray tube is a space heater with a side hustle. Switching one on and off billions of times a second remains a research problem.

A Coolidge X-ray tube, the hot-cathode design behind a century of medical X-rays. Almost all of the electrical energy going in leaves as heat, not X-rays. (Photo Credit: Daniel Frost Comstock / Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
A Coolidge X-ray tube, the hot-cathode design behind a century of medical X-rays. Almost all of the electrical energy going in leaves as heat, not X-rays. (Photo Credit: Daniel Frost Comstock / Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

Where Do Engineers Already Use Light, Ultraviolet And X-Rays To Send Data?

None of this makes short waves useless. They need a clear, straight path, and engineers have found four.

Glass. Fiber-optic cables carry infrared light at 1,550 nanometers through silica glass. The glass is clearest there. Scattering fades as waves get longer while absorption by the glass grows. The loss bottoms out where the two cross. A signal there travels 100 kilometers before dropping to one percent, a floor first reached in 1979.

Space. With no air in the way, lasers win. NASA's laser test on the Psyche spacecraft hit 267 megabits per second. Psyche was 53 million kilometers (33 million miles) away at the time. It later caught a beam fired from Earth at 460 million kilometers (290 million miles). Mars never gets farther from us than that. The bits rode on near-infrared light, and such links are expected to beat radio by up to a hundred times.

A sliver of ultraviolet. Ozone and oxygen wipe out sunlight between 200 and 280 nanometers before it reaches the ground. A detector tuned to that band sees a black sky at noon. Air molecules scatter those wavelengths hard. That lets a short link bounce its signal off the air and reach a receiver around a corner. The ozone layer, usually praised for keeping you alive, is here moonlighting as a lampshade.

X-rays, once. In 2019 NASA flew a device called the Modulated X-ray Source to the International Space Station. Its job was to flash X-ray pulses at the NICER telescope about 50 meters (165 feet) away. That was the first test of X-ray communication in space. The pitch was gigabit links for deep space, plus a way to talk to a capsule during re-entry. Hot plasma cuts off radio then, the blackout dramatized in Apollo 13. It was a test, not a working link.

The laser link to the Psyche spacecraft, which carried data from deep space on infrared light. Fine in a vacuum; hopeless across a kitchen. (Photo Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech)
The laser link to the Psyche spacecraft, which carried data from deep space on infrared light. Fine in a vacuum; hopeless across a kitchen. (Photo Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech)
The X-ray communication test on the International Space Station: the transmitter on the STP-H6 pallet, the NICER telescope as receiver, and about 50 meters of vacuum between them. (Photo Credit: NASA)
The X-ray communication test on the International Space Station: the transmitter on the STP-H6 pallet, the NICER telescope as receiver, and about 50 meters of vacuum between them. (Photo Credit: NASA)

So, Why Is Radio Used For Wireless Communication?

Put the three failures together and the choice makes itself. The airtight argument was wrong about information. Bits come from bandwidth and a clean signal, and a short wave only offers room. It was wrong about air, which eats ultraviolet and soft X-rays within meters. And it was wrong about safety, because the energy that makes an X-ray short also makes it ionizing.

Radio's wavelengths bend around a building, pass through plaster and do nothing to your DNA. They own the ground floor of the world, where the obstacles are. Light takes the long, straight, empty runs. That means the glass under the ocean and the gap between a spacecraft and a telescope. The split is not clean, either. Fiber wins on low loss as much as on wavelength, and a laser link slows as a spacecraft gets farther away.

The useful radio bands are crowded, and what happens when they fill up is its own story. But the fix so far has been to slice radio finer and move the straight-line traffic onto light, not to climb into X-rays. The one X-ray transmitter ever flown sat on a space station, pointed at a telescope 50 meters away, with no air in between.

References (click to expand)
  1. Introduction to the Electromagnetic Spectrum — NASA Science
  2. X-Rays — NASA Science
  3. Radio Waves — NASA Science
  4. Anatomy of an Electromagnetic Wave — NASA Science
  5. Technology Brief 30: Bandwidth, Data Rate, and Communication — University of Michigan EECS
  6. Shannon-Hartley Theorem — Wolfram MathWorld
  7. Basic Ozone Layer Science — US EPA
  8. X-Ray Mass Attenuation Coefficients: Air, Dry (Near Sea Level) — NIST
  9. X-Ray Mass Attenuation Coefficients, Table 2: Material Constants — NIST
  10. X-ray and Gamma-ray Astronomy Observing Platforms — NASA Imagine the Universe
  11. Fraunhofer Single Slit Diffraction — HyperPhysics, Georgia State University
  12. Radiation Basics — US EPA
  13. The impact of far-UVC radiation (200–230 nm) on pathogens, cells, skin, and eyes — PMC
  14. X-ray Production — HyperPhysics, Georgia State University
  15. First complete characterization of an X-Ray tube through combined measurements and Geant4 simulations — arXiv (2025)
  16. Optical and Photonic Glasses, Lecture 25: Optical Fibers C: Fiber Loss — Lehigh University
  17. Formation and applications of nanoparticles in silica optical fibers — arXiv (Blanc & Dussardier)
  18. Ultimate low-loss single-mode fibre at 1.55 μm — Miya, Terunuma, Hosaka & Miyashita, Electronics Letters (1979)
  19. NASA's Laser Comms Demo Makes Deep Space Record, Completes First Phase — NASA JPL
  20. Laser Communications Relay Demonstration (LCRD) Overview — NASA
  21. Modeling and characterization of ultraviolet scattering communication channels — in Advanced Optical Wireless Communication Systems, Cambridge University Press
  22. Ultraviolet Communications: Potential and State-Of-The-Art — Xu & Sadler, IEEE Communications Magazine (2008)
  23. NASA Set to Demonstrate X-ray Communications in Space — NASA
  24. ISS Utilization: XCOM — eoPortal
  25. Unlicensed Spectrum Subcommittee Report — NTIA (2010)