Table of Contents (click to expand)
The thick yellow “London fog” of Dickens and Sherlock Holmes was smog: river fog mixed with the smoke and sulfur dioxide from a million soft-coal fires. Inside each cold fog droplet, the sulfur dioxide met nitrogen dioxide, another coal-smoke gas, and the two turned into sulfuric acid, so the city was breathing an acid mist rather than plain water. The worst episode, the Great Smog of 5 to 9 December 1952, killed about 4,000 people by the official count (about 12,000 by a later study) and led to the Clean Air Act of 1956, after which the famous fogs stopped.
Open Bleak House and the first thing Dickens hands you is weather. “Fog everywhere,” he writes. Fog up the river, fog down the river, fog in the throats of old men wheezing by the fire. Sherlock Holmes walks out into the same fog. Every Victorian London you have ever pictured comes with that yellow haze.
The odd part is that the fog stopped.
The white fog that drifts off the Thames on a cold morning is still around. What went was the thick yellow “pea-souper” that could hide your own feet. It vanished within a decade of the 1950s and never came back. Weather does not retire.
Something else had been going on, and to see it you first need to know what turns fog into smog.
What Is Smog, And How Is It Different From Fog?
Breathe out on a cold morning, and the little cloud you make is fog in miniature: water condensing into droplets too small to fall. But water needs a surface to condense on, and in clean country air that surface is a speck of dust or salt, so the fog that forms is thin and white.
London’s air offered a far better surface: soot. Coal smoke is tiny carbon particles, and each one is a ready-made seed for a droplet. Water clings to the soot, so a city that burns coal makes fog more easily, holds it longer, and colors it.
That color is the tell. London smog was dirty yellow or brown, nothing like the white fog of the countryside, hence “pea-souper.” The word smog itself, smoke plus fog, was coined in London in 1905.
So smog is fog grown on soot, in air full of coal gases. Those gases came from the coal London chose to burn.

Why Did London Burn The Smokiest Coal It Could Find?
Soft coal, also called bituminous coal, is rich in volatile matter, the part of the coal that boils off as gas and tar before it burns, and more of that means more smoke. Hard coal, or anthracite, has far less of it, so it burns hot and clean.
Coal also carries sulfur, and when coal burns the sulfur leaves the chimney as sulfur dioxide gas, in direct proportion to how much sulfur went in. (Our article on why coal piles catch fire by themselves covers what else lurks in a lump of coal.)
London chose the smoky kind early. From the 1200s the forests shrank, and the city switched to cheap “sea-coal” shipped down from the northeast coast. King Edward I banned it in 1272, and the first person caught burning it was executed. People kept burning it anyway, because the clean hard coal was too expensive.
By the 1800s the smog was killing people, and nobody stopped burning coal, because coal was the Industrial Revolution. In 1952 the good hard coal was going for export, and a cheap soft grade called “nutty slack” went into London’s grates. Now picture a million of those grates lit at once in a cold snap.

What Caused The Killer Fog Of 1952?
Three things lined up in the first week of December 1952, and it helps to think of the city as a pot on a stove. First, the stove: the weeks before had been bitter, with heavy snow, so people were burning far more coal than usual, and a million grates were the burner under the pot.
Second, the lid. A big, slow area of high pressure parked over the region, and because sinking air warms, a layer of warm air ended up sitting on top of the colder air at street level. That upside-down arrangement is a temperature inversion, and it works like a lid on a pot. Smoke that would normally keep rising into cooler air meets air warmer than itself and stops.
Third, the water. Early on 5 December the sky was clear and the air near the ground damp. Overnight the ground had lost its heat to the clear sky, the damp air touching it cooled, and fog formed. The fog layer was only 100 to 200 meters deep, trapped under the lid.
Put the three together: a city pouring smoke and sulfur dioxide into the pot, a lid stopping any of it from leaving, and water to dissolve it in. Nothing there was unusual for London except how long the lid stayed on.

How Did Fog Turn Sulfur Dioxide Into Sulfuric Acid?
Sulfur dioxide on its own is a gas, and in dry air it turns into sulfate only slowly, over about a week, by which time the wind has carried it away. Fog changes the game, because sulfur dioxide dissolves in water, and inside a droplet it meets other dissolved gases and reacts far faster than it could in open air. The droplet is where the cooking happens.
The other ingredient turned out to be nitrogen dioxide, another coal-smoke gas. A 2016 study settled it in the lab: water exposed to sulfur dioxide alone made no sulfate, and adding nitrogen dioxide made the sulfate appear. One sulfur dioxide, two nitrogen dioxides and two waters make one sulfuric acid, plus a nitrous acid gas that mostly bubbles back out. The acid stays in the droplet.
The same work concluded that the London fog made its acid this way, helped along by the cold, the damp and the large fog droplets. London that week was a pot with the lid on, and the acid cooked inside every droplet.
Things got worse when the air warmed and the droplets shrank, because the water left and the acid did not: a dilute acid mist became a fine acid dust, small enough to breathe deep.

How Bad Was The Great Smog Of 1952?
The Met Office gives the daily bill. On each day of the smog, London’s chimneys sent up about 370 tonnes of sulfur dioxide, and by its estimate that became 800 tonnes of sulfuric acid.
That pair tests what you just learned. Each sulfur dioxide molecule picks up an oxygen and a water on its way to becoming sulfuric acid, which makes the acid about one and a half times heavier than the gas. So 370 tonnes of gas can make at most about 570 tonnes of pure acid, so the 800 must include water held in the droplets, or rest on a looser estimate. Either way: hundreds of tonnes of acid, every day, over one city.
The air monitor at County Hall agreed. Over three days the smoke in the air rose ninefold, and so did the sulfur dioxide, to the highest levels recorded there since measurements began, many times any modern limit.

The smog lasted five days, from 5 to 9 December. On the fourth day a light wind cleared the west of the city but not the east, and the smog came back that night. On the fifth a wind from the southwest lifted the lid and cleared it everywhere. Nobody had switched anything off.
In between, the city stopped working. In the east of London people could not see their feet, and plays were canceled because audiences could not see the stage. The first reported victims were prize cattle at a livestock show, which began to choke.

Then the human toll came in, and the number depends on how far out you count. The count at the time was about 4,000 more deaths than expected. The higher figure comes from a reassessment nearly fifty years later, which found that deaths stayed high for months, rejected the official explanation of a flu outbreak, and put the total at about 12,000 extra deaths over the three months that followed. The two figures count deaths over different stretches of time, so both are real.
How Did London Get Rid Of Smog? The Clean Air Act 1956
Not quickly, and not because of the prime minister. Winston Churchill was in London that week, and the project that keeps his archive has searched eighty million words of it without finding a single comment from him on the smog. Parliament said nothing about the fog for two months. The scenes in The Crown of a prime minister forced into action by the fog are artistic license.
When the question was finally asked, the minister for fuel replied that even good coal produces smoke, “but it also produces warmth, which is very much required at the present time.” It took pressure from the press, doctors and members of Parliament, and almost a year, before a committee on air pollution was set up.
The committee found that the biggest source of London’s smoke was home fires rather than factories, and the Clean Air Act 1956 followed, nearly 700 years after King Edward I tried the same thing. Dark smoke from any chimney became an offense. Any local authority could declare a smoke control area, and inside one, burning ordinary coal at home was banned, with grants for homeowners to switch to oil, gas or electricity.
People were given time to convert, so a fog in 1962 still killed 750 Londoners, and a second Clean Air Act followed. But the trend was set: coal fires gave way to gas and central heating, and power stations moved out of the city. Nothing on the scale of 1952 has happened again, and the pea-souper became a museum piece. That makes it a rare environmental story: a law that fixed the problem it was written for.

So, was the London fog really sulfuric acid? Partly, and the “partly” is the point. London sits in a river valley and makes real fog on its own. What the city added was everything that made it famous: the color, the smell, the staying power and the sting.
Soft coal, burned in a million grates, sent up soot, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide. The soot seeded the fog and made it thick and yellow. The fog dissolved the two gases and cooked them into sulfuric acid, hundreds of tonnes a day. A lid of warm air kept the pot over the city until the wind came back, and in December 1952 that ran long enough to kill thousands.
Then the fuel changed, and the chain broke at its first link, which is why the fog stopped. The yellow haze of the novels was mostly a heating problem, and it was solved. So the next time a Sherlock Holmes adaptation rolls the fog in, you will know what you are looking at: the memory of a chemical reaction that ran in the open over a great city for about a hundred years.
References (click to expand)
- The Great Smog of 1952 — UK Met Office
- Great Smog of London — Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Persistent sulfate formation from London Fog to Chinese haze — Wang, Zhang, Gomez et al., PNAS 113(48):13630, 2016
- Reassessment of the lethal London fog of 1952 — Bell & Davis, Environmental Health Perspectives 109(Suppl 3):389, 2001
- Fifty years on: the struggle for air quality in London since the great smog of December 1952 — Greater London Authority, 2002 (PDF)
- London’s Historic “Pea-Soupers” — EPA Journal, US Environmental Protection Agency, 1994
- AP-42 Section 1.1: Bituminous and Subbituminous Coal Combustion — US EPA
- AP-42 Section 1.2: Anthracite Coal Combustion — US EPA
- Churchill and the Great Smog: Another Example of Artistic License — The Churchill Project, Hillsdale College
- The Great London Smog of 1952: its consequences and contemporary relevance — Law and Justice in the 1950s, University of London Press
- Clean Air Act 1956 (as enacted) — legislation.gov.uk
- Sulfur dioxide — NIST Chemistry WebBook
- Sulfuric acid — NIST Chemistry WebBook
- Bleak House by Charles Dickens — Project Gutenberg







