Why Doesn't A Drone Hovering Inside A Train Slam Into The Back Wall When It Pulls Away?

Table of Contents (click to expand)

A drone hovering inside a closed train drifts a little toward the back when the train pulls away, then gets carried along, because the air inside is shoved forward by the rear wall while the much heavier drone lags behind. The push that moves the cabin air is tiny, so anything denser than air falls behind for a moment, anything as dense as air moves with it, and a helium balloon actually moves forward. A drone only keeps perfect pace if it leans forward by a few degrees, which a cheap drone with no position sensor cannot do on its own.

In August 2024, James of The Action Lab rented a box truck and climbed into the back. He set a cheap drone hovering in the middle of the cargo space. Then he asked the driver to floor it, and asked his viewers to pause the video and guess.

It is a better question than it looks. A fish in a bowl doesn't slam into the glass when you carry the bowl to the car. But you have certainly lurched backward on a subway as it pulled out of a station, and a drone isn't holding on to anything. So which is it? Does the drone hit the back wall, ride along, or hang over the platform as the carriage leaves without it?

The answer depends on something most people never think about: who is pushing the air.

What Happens If You Jump Inside A Moving Train?

Start with the easy case, a train cruising at a steady speed on straight track. Jump in the aisle and you land on the same spot. You, the seats and the air were all moving at train speed before you jumped. Nothing slowed you down in midair.

Physicists call this a frame of reference. A carriage moving at a steady speed is as good as one sitting still. No experiment inside it can tell the difference. That's why a fly can cruise around a car at highway speed without flapping like mad, as we covered in how a bug stays level in a speeding car. It's also why a bullet fired on a train behaves normally to the shooter.

A drone in a cruising train is just hovering in still air. It doesn't need to know the train is moving, and it doesn't care. The trouble starts when the speed changes.

Change the speed and everything loose tries to keep doing what it was doing. That stubbornness is inertia, and it is why you lose your balance stepping off a moving train. The floor speeds up under your feet; the rest of you wants to stay put. A standing passenger can only take a gentle pull-away of about 1 meter per second, every second, before grabbing a pole. That figure, written 1 m/s², is our test acceleration from here on.

A New York subway car. At a steady speed, the air in here is as still as the air in your living room. (Photo Credit: Kidfly182, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)
A New York subway car. At a steady speed, the air in here is as still as the air in your living room. (Photo Credit: Kidfly182, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

What Pushes The Air When A Train Pulls Away?

Air has inertia too. It's light, but a cubic meter of it weighs a little over a kilogram. When the train pulls away, that air also wants to stay behind. It can't, because the carriage is sealed. The back wall shoves the air nearest to it, that air shoves the air in front, and the whole lump gets pushed along.

To push air, you need a difference in pressure. The air piles up a little against the back wall. It sits at a touch higher pressure there than at the front, and that difference is the force that speeds up the air. Engineers treat the fluid in an accelerating tank as feeling a tilted version of ordinary gravity. That idea comes back later.

The size of that pressure difference follows a simple rule:

Δp = ρ × a × L

Here Δp is the pressure difference from back to front. ρ (the Greek letter rho) is the density of the air, a is how hard the train accelerates, and L is the carriage length. For a 20-meter (66-foot) carriage:

  1. Air density: ρ ≈ 1.2 kilograms per cubic meter.
  2. Acceleration: a = 1 m/s².
  3. Length: L = 20 meters.
  4. Δp = 1.2 × 1 × 20 = 24 pascals.

The air around you is already pressing on you at 101,325 pascals, a pressure called one atmosphere. The push that drags a whole carriage of air out of the station is about a four-thousandth of that. It matches the pressure difference between the floor of a quiet room and a point two meters up. Nobody on the platform notices it.

When the carriage speeds up, the air bunches up very slightly against the back wall. Inside the cabin, "down" now tilts toward the rear.
When the carriage speeds up, the air bunches up very slightly against the back wall. Inside the cabin, "down" now tilts toward the rear.

So Does A Drone In A Moving Train Hit The Back Wall?

That tiny push acts on everything in the carriage, the drone included. But it's sized to move air. Each object gets just enough push to speed up the air it shoves aside. This is Archimedes' rule for floating turned on its side. Buoyancy comes from the same pressure difference, only pointing up.

A drone's plastic, metal and battery are all far denser than air. Its push would speed up a drone-shaped bubble of air, but nowhere near the drone itself, so it falls behind.

That's what the truck showed. The drone in The Action Lab's test had no sense of its position, only a pressure sensor to hold its height. When the truck accelerated, it drifted toward the back, but only a little, and never hit the wall. Once the truck reached a steady speed, the drone hovered as if nothing had happened. It was like a passenger who slept through the whole station.

What saved it was drag. As the air started moving forward and the drone hung back, the drone felt a gentle breeze from behind. That breeze pushed it forward, and the faster it fell behind, the harder the breeze pushed. A short drift is the price of catching up.

The drone does not slam into the back wall. In a long, gentle pull-away it barely drifts at all. A harder start means a bigger drift before the air catches it.

Why Does A Helium Balloon Move Forward In A Car?

Now try the same thing with a balloon, and it gets stranger.

James added tape and string to a helium balloon until it hung in midair. The whole thing weighed about 17 grams, and its average density now matched the air around it. When the truck sped up or slowed down, the balloon didn't move at all. As he put it on camera, "It literally doesn't move at all." Being the same density as air, it gets exactly the push it needs from the air around it.

A plain helium balloon is lighter than the air it displaces. It gets more push than it needs, so it moves forward when a car speeds up. You can try it with a balloon on a string in the car. Brake, and it jerks toward the rear, while you and your coffee lurch forward.

Here's the cleanest way to see it. Inside a carriage that is speeding up, "down" tilts a little toward the back. A heavy thing falls "down," so it drifts back. A helium balloon floats "up," so it drifts forward. Einstein built general relativity on this idea. In a closed room, you can't tell acceleration from gravity. On a curve, "down" tilts toward the outside. Heavy things drift outward, the centrifugal effect you feel in your seat, and a helium balloon leans in.

One carriage, three passengers, three directions. Density decides which way each one goes.
One carriage, three passengers, three directions. Density decides which way each one goes.

How Does A Drone Keep Up With An Accelerating Train?

A drone that wants to hold its spot can't wait for the breeze. It has to fly forward, and a drone flies forward by leaning. Tip the propellers forward and part of their thrust pushes the drone ahead instead of holding it up.

The lean it needs depends on how hard the train accelerates compared with gravity:

tan θ = a ÷ g

Here θ (theta) is the lean angle, a is the train's acceleration and g is gravity's pull, 9.81 m/s². For our test pull-away, that works out to a lean of about six degrees. It is the same tilt as the new "down" from earlier. To hold its place, the drone leans into the new "down."

A cheap drone can't do this on its own, because it has no idea it's falling behind. A camera drone like the DJI Mavic 3 Pro holds its spot with satellites or with cameras watching the ground. Lose both, and the manual warns it drifts with the wind and "will not be able to hover or brake automatically." The same manual has a blunter rule: "DO NOT take off from moving objects, such as cars and ships." Inside a sealed carriage, the cameras see a floor that moves with the train, which helps. Satellites, on the other hand, measure position against the ground outside.

Open the doors and the whole bargain changes. James also opened the back of the truck on the move. Air began to circulate, flowing out along the roof and back in along the floor. The cabin air no longer belongs to the truck, and the calm bubble a drone relies on starts leaking out the back.

A drone flies forward by tilting so that some of its thrust points ahead. To keep pace with a speeding-up train, it would need the same lean. (Photo Credit: Josh Sorenson, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)
A drone flies forward by tilting so that some of its thrust points ahead. To keep pace with a speeding-up train, it would need the same lean. (Photo Credit: Josh Sorenson, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)
The harder the train accelerates, the further a drone has to lean to keep up. A gentle pull-away needs about six degrees.
The harder the train accelerates, the further a drone has to lean to keep up. A gentle pull-away needs about six degrees.

So, Why Doesn't A Drone Hovering Inside A Train Slam Into The Back Wall?

Because the air saves it, just not right away. When the train pulls away, the back wall pushes the air, and the air pushes everything floating in it. That push is tiny, sized only to move air. A drone is far denser than air, so it falls behind for a moment. Then the breeze from the moving air catches it and carries it along.

Density decides the direction, and inertia decides how big the drift is. Heavier than air drifts back. Exactly as heavy as air stays put, like the fish in its bowl. Lighter than air drifts forward. The drift grows with a harder start and shrinks when the drone's shape catches more breeze. We could not find a measurement for a real train, so the truck test is the best evidence we have.

If you're tempted to try it on your morning commute, the drone will probably survive. The other passengers, and the rules for flying drones, may be less forgiving. For the same physics at no risk, take a helium balloon into the car on your next birthday and watch it lean into every turn.

An empty London Underground carriage. Plenty of room for a drone, though the drone would still need a ticket. (Photo Credit: Matt Brown, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0)
An empty London Underground carriage. Plenty of room for a drone, though the drone would still need a ticket. (Photo Credit: Matt Brown, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0)
References (click to expand)
  1. An Investigation of Acceleration and Jerk Profiles of Public Transportation Vehicles — ASEE Annual Conference, 2008
  2. Rigid-Body Acceleration (ME 320 Lesson 03E) — John Cimbala, Penn State
  3. Beginner's Guide to Propulsion and EngineSim: Fuel and Air Relationships - Answers — NASA Glenn Research Center
  4. NIST Guide to the SI, Appendix B.8: Factors for Units Listed Alphabetically — NIST
  5. Pressure: Buoyancy — HyperPhysics, Georgia State University
  6. Will a Drone Be Pushed Backwards Inside an Accelerating Truck? — The Action Lab (YouTube, 2024)
  7. Buoyant Balloon: Float Forward with Fluid Physics — Scientific American
  8. Experiments With A Helium Balloon — Alaska Science Forum, Geophysical Institute, University of Alaska Fairbanks
  9. Einstein's Equivalence Principle — PH S 1150 Basic Astronomy, Chicago State University (LibreTexts)
  10. DJI Mavic 3 Pro User Manual — DJI