Why Do LED Bulbs Glow Faintly When The Switch Is Off?

Table of Contents (click to expand)
An LED bulb glows faintly with the switch off because the wire that feeds the switch and the wire that returns from it run side by side for meters inside one cable, and two wires with plastic between them let a trickle of alternating current across even though the switch has broken the circuit. That trickle is about a thousandth of what the bulb draws when lit, far too little to warm an old filament bulb but enough to light an LED in a dark room, and lit switches or smart dimmers fitted without a neutral wire add a standby current of their own through the bulb. The glow is harmless in almost every case; the one worth an electrician's visit is a switch that was wired into the return wire instead of the supply wire, which leaves the light fitting live when it looks off.

The bedroom light went off at eleven, and at two in the morning it was still faintly on. Not bright. A dull orange ember inside the frosted dome. You only notice it once the rest of the room is black, and then you cannot stop noticing it.

The owner did the sensible things in the sensible order. New bulb: same ember. New switch: same ember. Then an electrician, a ladder, a meter and an invoice. The verdict: the wiring was fine and the bulb was “just doing that.” Which is true, and is also not an explanation.

The explanation is a piece of physics the house has been doing in secret since the day it was wired. Electricians call the glow ghosting. The switch is open and the circuit is broken. The bulb is still being fed, by a route that has nothing to do with the switch at all. To see how, you need to know what a capacitor is, and why your walls are full of them.

The ember you only see after midnight: a bulb glowing in an otherwise dark room. (Photo Credit: Subasis Mahat, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
The ember you only see after midnight: a bulb glowing in an otherwise dark room. (Photo Credit: Subasis Mahat, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

How Does A Wire In The Wall Act Like A Capacitor?

Take any two pieces of metal, keep them from touching, and you have built a capacitor. Two sheets of foil with a sheet of paper between them is the classic version. Put a voltage across the pair and charge piles up on one sheet and drains off the other. With a steady battery that is the end of it. Once the sheets are charged, nothing more moves. Mains electricity is different. The voltage reverses direction fifty or sixty times a second. The sheets are forever charging one way, then the other, and a small current sloshes back and forth through the wires that feed them. Nothing crosses the gap. The current still flows in the circuit.

Now look at how a ceiling light is wired. The supply arrives at the light fitting. One wire runs from there down to the wall switch, and a second wire runs from the switch back up to the lamp. The two wires share one cable, a few millimeters apart, all the way from ceiling to switch. When the switch is off, the first wire is still live. The second is meant to be dead. Between them sits plastic insulation. So: two conductors, an insulator, and an alternating voltage. That is a capacitor, several meters long.

The switch is open, but the feed wire and the switched wire share one cable, and that cable is a capacitor. The current figures are the upper bound for ten meters of cable.
The switch is open, but the feed wire and the switched wire share one cable, and that cable is a capacitor. The current figures are the upper bound for ten meters of cable.

How big a capacitor? Two parallel wires have a capacitance per meter that depends only on their spacing compared with their thickness:

C per meter = πε0 ÷ ln(d ÷ a)

Here d is the distance between the wire centers, a is the wire radius, ε0 (epsilon-nought) is a fixed constant of nature, and ln is the natural logarithm. For wires a few millimeters apart the formula gives tens of picofarads per meter in air. Wrapped in plastic, which stores charge better than air, real cable comes out around a hundred picofarads per meter, which is also the figure electricians quote from experience. A picofarad is a millionth of a millionth of a farad, so this is a feeble capacitor. It is also a long one. Walk the numbers for a ten-meter (33 ft) switch run:

  1. Ten meters at a hundred picofarads per meter is a thousand picofarads, or one nanofarad.
  2. The current an alternating voltage drives through a capacitor is I = V × 2πf × C, where V is the voltage, f is the mains frequency and C the capacitance. On a UK or Australian supply, 230 V at 50 Hz, that is 230 × 2π × 50 × one nanofarad, which comes to about 72 microamps.
  3. On a US or Canadian supply, 120 V at 60 Hz, the same cable passes about 45 microamps.

Those are ceilings. The bulb's own electronics stand in the path and take only part of what the cable offers. But the scale is right: tens of microamps, give or take, roughly a thousand times less than the bulb draws when it is lit. A current that small cannot do much. The question is whether it can do anything you would notice.

Why Didn't Old Incandescent Bulbs Glow When Switched Off?

The leak is as old as the wiring. Houses were cabled this way when the only bulb on sale was a filament. Nobody ever saw a ghost, because a filament is a terrible detector of small currents.

An incandescent bulb makes light by heat. Current forces its way through a thin tungsten wire, the wire gets hot, and hot things glow. But the glow only becomes visible at high temperatures. At 800 °C (1,500 °F) a solid still radiates almost all its light as invisible infrared. Only a trace of red creeps into the visible. A working filament runs far hotter than that, up at white heat.

A tungsten filament at working temperature. Below a few hundred degrees it makes no visible light at all, and a stray current of microamps cannot even warm it. (Photo Credit: Gauravggs, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
A tungsten filament at working temperature. Below a few hundred degrees it makes no visible light at all, and a stray current of microamps cannot even warm it. (Photo Credit: Gauravggs, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Heat from a current rises with the square of the current. A 60-watt bulb on a US supply draws about half an amp. A stray current of fifty microamps is ten thousand times smaller, so it delivers a hundred million times less heat. The filament does not get warm. The trickle was there every night for a century, and the bulb had no way to show it.

An LED does not need heat. It is a diode, a chip that passes current one way, and it makes light straight from the electrons crossing it, which is why it is so efficient. Below a turn-on voltage of a couple of volts it does almost nothing. Above that point the current rises exponentially with the voltage, and more current means more light. There is no warm-up and no threshold of heat to climb. If the voltage is there, some light comes out, and a dark-adapted eye is remarkably good at seeing “some.” The bulb did not create the leak. It exposed it.

Why Do Smart Dimmers And Lit Switches Make LED Ghosting Worse?

Capacitance is the cause that comes with the house. Other causes you buy and install yourself.

A smart dimmer has a radio in it, and the radio has to stay awake to hear the app. Lutron says its wireless dimmers “still need to receive a small amount of power to be able to receive RF signals.” That power has to come from somewhere, and in Lutron's words “this tiny bit of current can cause this bulb ghosting phenomenon.” If the switch box has no neutral wire, the only way back to the supply for that standby current is through the bulb. The switch is off, and the bulb is its power cord.

The glow-in-the-dark switch is the older version of the same trick. A small neon lamp behind the rocker lights up so you can find it at night, and it is fed through the lamp circuit. Leviton calls ghosting “a common problem seen with neon illuminated switches.” Its LED-illuminated switches are built to avoid it.

A wall switch pulled out of its box. Whether a neutral wire is present here decides where a smart switch's standby current goes. (Photo Credit: Kurtkaiser, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)
A wall switch pulled out of its box. Whether a neutral wire is present here decides where a smart switch's standby current goes. (Photo Credit: Kurtkaiser, Wikimedia Commons, CC0)

Enough of this landed on inspectors' desks that the rules changed. Electronic switches had been sending their standby current down the ground wire, which exists for faults and is meant to carry nothing in normal use. From its 2011 edition the US National Electrical Code began requiring a neutral at most lighting switch boxes so the gadgets would have a proper return path, and since January 2020 such switches “shall not introduce current on the equipment grounding conductor during normal operation.” The ghost glow has a regulatory paper trail.

Is LED Ghosting A Fire Hazard?

A bulb ghosting on stray current is not dangerous. Tens of microamps cannot heat anything. The bulb's electronics are built for the full mains voltage, and an LED left on all night runs cool, dim or bright. Nor is the bulb “storing” light. A white LED makes blue light, and a phosphor coating turns it white. Cut the blue light and the phosphor goes dark within about sixty billionths of a second. A glow that lasts all night is being powered, full stop.

One cause is different, and it deserves a few minutes of your attention. A light circuit has a live wire that brings power in and a neutral that carries it back. The switch belongs in the live wire, so that with the switch off the fitting is dead. Put the switch in the neutral by mistake and it still turns the light off, since the loop is broken either way. But now the whole fitting stays live. Anyone who changes that bulb is handling a live socket. The US National Electrical Code forbids it in plain words. The code's name for the neutral is the “grounded conductor.” Its rule: switches “shall not disconnect the grounded conductor of a circuit.”

Telling the causes apart does not need a meter. If the glow comes and goes with the brand of bulb, it is the cable. The same if it shows only on the fitting with the longest run to its switch. If there is a smart dimmer or a lit switch on that circuit, it is the switch. If every bulb on one switch glows, whatever you screw in, call an electrician. The same if the glow appeared after wiring work. Have them check which wire the switch is in. That check is not a job for a screwdriver and a hunch.

How Do You Stop LED Bulbs Glowing When Switched Off?

The stray current is tiny and it has to go somewhere. Every fix is a version of giving it somewhere easier to go than through the LED.

The electrician's version is a small resistor or a mains-rated capacitor wired across the lamp terminals. It swallows the trickle before the bulb's electronics see it. Lutron's own last-resort advice for a ghosting circuit is the same idea with no tools: “change out one bulb for an incandescent/halogen.” One filament in the circuit soaks up the current and, as we saw, never notices it.

The other fixes attack the source. A smart dimmer with a neutral wire sends its standby current home the proper way, not through the lamp. An LED-lit switch replaces a neon one. And bulbs differ. Each brand's electronics ignore a different amount of trickle. Swapping bulbs can cure the glow, or do nothing at all. Opening a switch box or a fitting is mains work. In every country this site is read in, that is a job for a licensed electrician.

Same socket, different electronics. Each of these ignores a different amount of stray current, which is why one bulb ghosts and its neighbor does not. (Photo Credit: Geoffrey A. Landis, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0)
Same socket, different electronics. Each of these ignores a different amount of stray current, which is why one bulb ghosts and its neighbor does not. (Photo Credit: Geoffrey A. Landis, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0)

So, Why Do LED Bulbs Glow Faintly When The Switch Is Off?

To see the bedroom effect at full size, go to a hillside near Bath in England in February 2004. Richard Box was the artist in residence at the University of Bristol's physics department. He stood about 1,300 scavenged fluorescent tubes on end in a field under a high-voltage power line. Nothing was wired to anything. As night fell, the field lit up. A fluorescent tube needs a kick of up to four times its running voltage to start. The electric field around the line supplied that kick through the air. Box reported two-millimeter sparks jumping between his fingers and the tubes. “At moments like that,” he said, “I'd start thinking, ‘Okay, I should go home now.’”

One tube, no wires: a fluorescent lamp lit by the electric field under a high-voltage line, the same physics as the bedroom bulb with the voltage turned up. (Photo Credit: BaronAlaric, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
One tube, no wires: a fluorescent lamp lit by the electric field under a high-voltage line, the same physics as the bedroom bulb with the voltage turned up. (Photo Credit: BaronAlaric, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

That is the same physics as the ceiling light. An alternating voltage on one conductor pushes charge back and forth in any conductor near it, with nothing but air or plastic in between. The push is stronger the higher the voltage, and the longer the two run side by side. Under a transmission line the voltage is enormous, and the “other conductor” is a gas-filled tube that needs only a kick to light. The whole field glows. In your wall it is mains voltage and a few meters of cable, so the current is microamps. The same effect, far down the scale.

The bulb glows because the switch only breaks one path, and the cable was offering a second one all along. For a century the only lamp on the market needed heat to shine, and microamps make no heat. The LED needs voltage, not heat, and it answers the trickle with light. Which cause is doing the work in a given house is messier. The length of the switch run, the brand of bulb and any smart or lit switch on the circuit all pull in different directions, and often two of them are at it at once. The one case that is not a curiosity is the switch wired into the neutral. That is why the diagnosis above matters more than the fix.

And the cheapest fix of all is one you can do from the floor. In a fitting with more than one socket, screw in one old filament bulb and let the trickle warm a tungsten wire that will never, ever notice.

References (click to expand)
  1. ECE 303 Handout 6: Capacitance of Parallel Metal Wires — Farhan Rana, Cornell University
  2. Accurately Characterizing a Light Emitting Diode (PHY335 junior electronics lab) — Stony Brook University
  3. Colour: Physical and chemical causes of colour, Incandescence — Encyclopaedia Britannica
  4. LED Basics — U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy
  5. Dispersion characteristic of photoluminescence decay times of gadolinium co-doped YAG:Ce phosphors — Journal of Physics: Conference Series 830, 012161 (open-access copy)
  6. Ghosting / Blinking LED Lights with Caseta Dimmers — Lutron Support
  7. What is LED ghosting? — Leviton Product Support
  8. Do We Need a Grounded Conductor at that Switch Location or Not? — IAEI Magazine
  9. The Apprentice's Guide to Article 404 — EC&M
  10. Making light of physics (FIELD, Richard Box) — University of Bristol Annual Report 2003/2004
  11. Fluorescent lamp — Encyclopaedia Britannica
  12. 1000+ Fluorescent lights powered by overhead cables — Make: magazine