Why Is an MRI Machine So Loud? (Hint: It's Not the Giant Magnet)

Table of Contents (click to expand)

The giant magnet in an MRI is silent: its current never switches off, so nothing in it moves. The knocking comes from three smaller “gradient” coils that the scanner switches on and off to work out where in your body each signal came from. A current switched on inside a strong magnetic field gets a kick, the same kick that drives a loudspeaker cone. So the scanner is a loudspeaker you lie inside. The loudest scans run at 110 to 120 decibels with peaks above 130, and each type of scan plays its own tune. Quieter scans exist, but they cost speed or image types, so the loud version is still the default.

One hundred and thirty decibels. That is the peak measured inside a 3 tesla MRI scanner during a fast brain scan, in the same tunnel patients lie in for up to an hour.

If you have had an MRI, you remember it. The technologist hands you earplugs, slides you in, and the knocking starts. A knock, then a buzz, then a chirp, each lasting a few minutes. A machine that costs as much as a house sounds like a building site.

The obvious suspect is the magnet. It is enormous, it is powerful, and it is the one part everyone has heard of. It is also the one part making no sound at all.

Is The Giant Magnet Making All That Noise?

No. The main magnet is a coil of special wire, several miles of it, bathed in liquid helium. At that temperature the wire loses all electrical resistance, which is what superconducting means. Once current is flowing in the coil, it keeps flowing for years, like a spinning top that never slows down. Nothing switches, nothing moves, and the field stays on day and night. That is why you must remove every scrap of metal before you go near it.

A steady field with no moving parts makes no sound. The knocking comes from a part that switches, fast and hard.

A 3 tesla clinical scanner. The ring you lie inside holds a magnet whose current has been flowing, without a power supply, since the day it was installed. (Photo Credit: KasugaHuang, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
A 3 tesla clinical scanner. The ring you lie inside holds a magnet whose current has been flowing, without a power supply, since the day it was installed. (Photo Credit: KasugaHuang, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

What Does An MRI Need Besides A Big Magnet?

The steady field lines up the hydrogen atoms in your body. A radio pulse nudges them, and as they settle back they send out a faint radio signal of their own. That signal is the raw material of the picture.

The catch is that the steady field is the same everywhere, so every part of you sends back the same signal. Imagine a piano where every key plays middle C. Press any key and you hear the same note, so you cannot tell which key was pressed. That is what the scanner hears from a uniform field: one note from everywhere, and no idea where it came from.

The fix is to tune the piano. Make the field a little stronger at your head than at your feet, and each slice of your body gets its own note. Now the scanner can tell where a signal came from by its pitch. That tilt in the field is called a gradient, and three extra coils make it, one for each direction, tucked just inside the main magnet. The scanner switches them on, off and over many times a second, retuning the piano for every slice of the picture. The main magnet holds still. The gradient coils do all the running around.

Cross-section of a scanner. The superconducting magnet sits in a helium bath on the outside; the gradient coils sit just inside it, wrapped around the bore where you lie. (Photo Credit: ChumpusRex, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
Cross-section of a scanner. The superconducting magnet sits in a helium bath on the outside; the gradient coils sit just inside it, wrapped around the bore where you lie. (Photo Credit: ChumpusRex, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

So Is An MRI Scanner Really A Giant Loudspeaker?

Yes, and not as a figure of speech. Open a home speaker and you find a thin coil of wire glued to the back of the cone, sitting in the gap of a small magnet. Send a current through the coil and the magnet kicks it sideways. Reverse the current and the kick reverses. Feed the coil a music signal and it kicks back and forth in step with the music. The cone shoves the air, and that is sound.

The kick follows a simple rule. A stronger magnet, a bigger current or a longer wire all mean a harder kick. It is the same force that bends a stream of water near a strong magnet and turns every electric motor.

An MRI has the speaker's three parts, scaled up until they are absurd. The small magnet becomes the superconducting magnet. The thin voice coil becomes the gradient coils, fed by amplifiers that push hundreds of amps through them with about a dozen Formula 1 cars' worth of power. In a 3 tesla scanner, a few hundred amps through a single meter of wire gets a kick equal to the weight of a grown adult, and the coil holds many meters. The scanner reverses that current thousands of times per scan, and every reversal kicks the coil the other way.

The cone becomes the coil's own housing, which flexes with every kick and shoves the air in the tunnel. So an MRI is a loudspeaker with a monster magnet and hundreds of amps in the coil. You lie inside it, which is not where the audio industry recommends sitting.

A bass speaker, cut open: 1 is the permanent magnet, 2 the voice coil, 3 the suspension, 4 the cone. Swap the magnet for a 3 tesla superconductor and the coil for one carrying hundreds of amps, and you have an MRI. (Photo Credit: Svjo, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
A bass speaker, cut open: 1 is the permanent magnet, 2 the voice coil, 3 the suspension, 4 the cone. Swap the magnet for a 3 tesla superconductor and the coil for one carrying hundreds of amps, and you have an MRI. (Photo Credit: Svjo, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

Why Does Every MRI Scan Sound Different?

Because each type of scan is a different tune for the coils. The scanner is the speaker, and the pattern of current it sends through the gradients, called a pulse sequence, is the sheet music. The magnet is fixed, so the kick rises and falls with the current. Slow, spaced pulses give a slow knock. Rapid back-and-forth switching gives a buzz.

Most scans keep to the lower notes, which is the knocking you hear for most of the session. The fast diffusion scan is the odd one out. It plays a higher note with overtones stacked on top, like a siren with a grudge, because it switches the gradients hardest. It is among the loudest scans, at 110 to 120 decibels.

The beeping is not a side effect of the imaging. The beeping is the imaging, one gradient switch at a time.

The kick on the coil, and so the sound, follows the current waveform. A sequence with slow, spaced pulses knocks; one that flips the current rapidly buzzes. Schematic, not measured data.
The kick on the coil, and so the sound, follows the current waveform. A sequence with slow, spaced pulses knocks; one that flips the current rapidly buzzes. Schematic, not measured data.

How Loud Is An MRI, And Why Are Stronger Scanners Louder?

Loud enough to need a yardstick. On the decibel scale, normal conversation sits around 60 to 70, a rock concert at 94 to 110, and a siren above that, according to the NIH's hearing institute.

Now the scanner. Measured in one lab, a standard scan averaged about 90 decibels on a 1.5 tesla machine, roughly a motorcycle, and about 113 on a 3 tesla machine, a rock concert at full tilt. The fast diffusion scan on the 3 tesla machine peaked at 131, siren territory. A 7 tesla research scanner is louder again.

Why does a stronger magnet mean a louder scan? Back to the kick. Double the magnet and you double the kick for the same current, so the coil hits the air twice as hard. On the decibel scale that adds about 6, which the ear hears as clearly louder but not twice as loud. Real machines differ in more than their magnets, so the measured jumps do not follow the rule exactly.

There is a legal ceiling. US regulators cap the peak at 140 decibels, and cap the average too, on the assumption that you are wearing hearing protection. That is why the earplugs are not optional. Volunteers in the lab above rated earplugs plus headphones as better than either alone.

Measured sound levels. Left: the same six scans on a 1.5 and a 3 tesla scanner in one lab (Hattori et al., 2007). Right: five scans on a 3 and a 7 tesla scanner in another (Akbar et al., 2023). The dashed line is the 99 decibel hearing-protection limit.
Measured sound levels. Left: the same six scans on a 1.5 and a 3 tesla scanner in one lab (Hattori et al., 2007). Right: five scans on a 3 and a 7 tesla scanner in another (Akbar et al., 2023). The dashed line is the 99 decibel hearing-protection limit.

Will MRIs Ever Be Quiet?

Engineers have worked on it for decades, and a review of the methods lays out the toolkit. Each tool buys some decibels, and each has a bill attached.

Cancel the kick. Wind the coil so the kicks on different parts of it work against each other, like two people shoving a door from opposite sides. The door stays put. Worth about 10 decibels.

Line the tunnel. Absorbing linings do what carpets and curtains do for a room, up to 30 decibels, but they add weight and shrink the tunnel.

Play anti-noise. Active noise cancellation near the ear, the trick in noise-cancelling headphones, averages about 20.

Change the music. The most elegant fix is to stop kicking the coil. A “silent” sequence moves the gradient in small steps instead of sharp flips, walking down the stairs instead of jumping. In one hospital's test, the conventional scan measured 105 decibels and the silent one 69, the sound level of the empty room.

So why is your scan still loud? Because each fix trades something: weight, tunnel space, scan time or the types of image it can make, and the hospital wants the picture more.

That is the whole story. The machine that makes the picture is, in its bones, a loudspeaker. The giant magnet is silent. The picture needs the field tilted, the tilt comes from three gradient coils, and every time the scanner switches hundreds of amps through them inside that magnet, the coils get kicked. The kick shakes the housing, the housing shoves the air, and you are lying in the tunnel. The pattern of switching is the tune, which is why one scan knocks and another buzzes, and a stronger magnet kicks harder. Until hospitals pay for the quiet version, take the earplugs and the headphones, and let the loudspeaker play.

How much each approach takes off, as reported by its source. The figures were measured under different conditions and do not simply add together.
How much each approach takes off, as reported by its source. The figures were measured under different conditions and do not simply add together.
References (click to expand)
  1. Measurement and Evaluation of the Acoustic Noise of a 3 Tesla MR Scanner — Hattori, Fukatsu & Ishigaki, Nagoya Journal of Medical Science, 2007
  2. Overview of Methods for Noise and Heat Reduction in MRI Gradient Coils — Winkler & Motovilova, Frontiers in Physics, 2022 (PMC)
  3. Acoustic Noise Levels in High-field Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanners — Akbar et al., OTO Open, 2023 (PMC)
  4. Acoustic noise reduction in MRI using Silent Scan: an initial experience — Alibek et al., Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, 2014
  5. Criteria for Significant Risk Investigations of Magnetic Resonance Diagnostic Devices — U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 2014
  6. Noise-Induced Hearing Loss — National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, NIH
  7. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) — National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering, NIH
  8. MRI scan — NHS
  9. The Basics of MRI, Chapter 9: Imaging Hardware — Joseph P. Hornak, Rochester Institute of Technology
  10. Magnetic Force on a Current-Carrying Conductor — OpenStax College Physics 2e, 22.7
  11. Sound Intensity and Sound Level — OpenStax College Physics 2e, 17.3
  12. Gradient Performance and Gradient Amplifier Power — Mathias Blasche, Siemens Healthineers MAGNETOM World white paper
  13. Speaker Building: Energy Transduction — Drexel University MET-lab handout