Why A Bubble Released At The Bottom Of The Mariana Trench Would Never Reach The Surface

Table of Contents (click to expand)

At the floor of the Mariana Trench the water presses down with about 1,100 times the air pressure at sea level and sits at about 2 °C, and under that squeeze no everyday gas behaves like a gas: methane and air are crushed into dense fluids hundreds of times heavier than at the surface, while carbon dioxide becomes a liquid heavier than seawater and sinks. A methane or air blob still rises, but within about ten seconds it grows an ice-like shell of gas hydrate and then dissolves into the water as it climbs at roughly a quarter of a meter per second. In the Black Sea, plumes of coated bubbles have been tracked climbing 1,300 meters and still dying 740 meters short of the surface, so from eleven kilometers down nothing arrives at the top.

Where does a bubble go when you let it loose at the bottom of the Mariana Trench?

The question came up on a forum this month, phrased less politely. (The gas was supposed to have come out of a diver.) Thousands of people weighed in, and almost all of them agreed. The bubble rises, it swells as the pressure drops, and after a long climb it pops at the surface somewhere in the Pacific. It is a sensible picture. It is also wrong at every step.

The bubble does not swell on the way up, because it never gets far enough up. It does not stay a bubble for long. And depending on which gas you picked, it may not rise at all. Three gases, three fates, and none of them ends with a pop in the sunshine.

How Much Pressure Is There At The Bottom Of The Mariana Trench?

Air is pressing on you right now, around fifteen pounds on every square inch of skin. We call that amount one atmosphere. Water is far heavier than air, so underwater the pressure climbs fast. Every ten meters of seawater adds roughly another atmosphere. The Challenger Deep is the deepest pocket of the Mariana Trench. It lies about 10,935 meters down, nearly seven miles. Divide by ten and you have the answer: about 1,100 atmospheres.

A mooring lowered to the floor has measured it. Its gauge read 11,161 decibars, with the sensor twenty-five meters above the seabed. A decibar is close to the weight of one meter of seawater. In the units of a tire gauge, that is about 16,000 psi. The same instrument logged the temperature: 2.45 °C (36 °F). The trench is not hot. The deep ocean is cold everywhere, and we have a whole article on why.

Water itself hardly notices, losing only about five percent of its volume under that load. Gas is a different story.

Sonar map of the Challenger Deep, the deepest pocket of the Mariana Trench. The darkest purple is nearly 11 kilometers below the ship. (Photo Credit: Cassandra Bongiovanni, Heather A. Stewart and Alan J. Jamieson, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)
Sonar map of the Challenger Deep, the deepest pocket of the Mariana Trench. The darkest purple is nearly 11 kilometers below the ship. (Photo Credit: Cassandra Bongiovanni, Heather A. Stewart and Alan J. Jamieson, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

Is A Bubble Even A Gas At The Bottom Of The Mariana Trench?

Squeeze a gas and it shrinks, because a gas is mostly empty space between molecules. Keep squeezing and the molecules end up jammed as close together as they are in a liquid. At that point the stuff in your bubble is no longer a gas. It is a dense fluid.

Whether it rises or sinks now depends on one thing: is it lighter or heavier than the water around it? (The squeeze itself is covered in what happens to a gas when its pressure is increased.)

The result, at two degrees and trench pressure, is dramatic. At the surface, methane weighs less than a gram per liter. Down there it is crushed to about 365 kilograms per cubic meter. Call it five hundred times denser. A liter of methane from a kitchen stove, taken to the trench floor, would fit inside a sugar cube. Nitrogen, the main ingredient of air, ends up at about 620 kilograms per cubic meter. Carbon dioxide stops being a gas a few hundred meters down. At the floor it is a true liquid, at about twelve hundred kilograms per cubic meter.

Now compare those with the water. Seawater at the surface weighs a little over a thousand kilograms per cubic meter. Crushed by the full trench, it only reaches about 1,075. A blob of methane or nitrogen is still far lighter than that, so it rises. Carbon dioxide is heavier. A carbon dioxide "bubble" at the bottom of the Mariana Trench falls.

How dense methane, nitrogen and carbon dioxide become at 2 °C as the water deepens, against seawater itself. Methane and nitrogen stay lighter than water all the way down; liquid carbon dioxide crosses the seawater line at roughly 3,000 meters and is heavier below it.
How dense methane, nitrogen and carbon dioxide become at 2 °C as the water deepens, against seawater itself. Methane and nitrogen stay lighter than water all the way down; liquid carbon dioxide crosses the seawater line at roughly 3,000 meters and is heavier below it.

Why Would A Carbon Dioxide Bubble Sink Instead Of Rising?

Liquid carbon dioxide is unusual: it squashes far more than water does. Near the surface it is lighter than seawater. But the deeper you go, the more it compresses, and at a few thousand meters it overtakes the water. Below about 3,000 meters it is the heavier of the two. Engineers have studied storing it on the deep seabed for that reason: it sinks and pools.

The ocean does this on its own. Off Japan there is a pond of liquid carbon dioxide sitting under the seabed. And a vent field nicknamed Champagne, on a volcano in the Mariana island chain, leaks droplets of liquid carbon dioxide. It sits about 1,600 meters down. The droplets rise through the water wrapped in a milky skin. The scientists who found them said the droplets were sticky and clung to their robot like clumps of grapes.

The trench floor is seven kilometers deeper than Champagne. Down there a carbon dioxide bubble is heavier than the water from the start. It settles onto the mud as a drop, grows the same milky skin, and dissolves into the water. Its journey to the surface is minus a few centimeters.

The Champagne vent field on NW Eifuku volcano in the Mariana Arc, about 1,600 meters down. The small pale spheres at top right are droplets of liquid carbon dioxide, each wrapped in a skin of hydrate. (Photo Credit: NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
The Champagne vent field on NW Eifuku volcano in the Mariana Arc, about 1,600 meters down. The small pale spheres at top right are droplets of liquid carbon dioxide, each wrapped in a skin of hydrate. (Photo Credit: NOAA, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

How Does A Methane Bubble Grow An Ice Shell In Ten Seconds?

Methane and air blobs are lighter than water even at the trench floor, so they do start upward. They do not travel far as naked gas.

Water molecules can arrange themselves into tiny cages. A gas molecule can sit trapped inside each cage. The result is a solid that looks and feels like ice but fizzes and burns. It is called a gas hydrate. The gas is held in the cage, not chemically bonded to the water, so the solid needs cold and pressure to hold together. In most of the ocean those conditions arrive below about 500 meters of water depth. The trench floor is twenty times deeper than that.

How fast does the shell form? Researchers filmed methane seeps at six sites off North America. Bubbles that lingered on the seabed were coated within about ten seconds. Bubbles that broke free at once grew their coat within the first meter and a half of rise.

An air bubble fares no better, with air hydrate instead of methane hydrate. Antarctica does this too. Air bubbles trapped in the ice sheet turn into hydrate once enough ice piles on top. So whichever lighter-than-water gas you released, within seconds you no longer have a bubble. You have a rising pellet of methane ice, or air ice, with gas inside.

A bubble trap over a methane seep in the Gulf of Mexico. The bubbles caught in the chamber have already turned into white methane hydrate at the top. (Photo Credit: NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Gulf of Mexico 2012 Expedition, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
A bubble trap over a methane seep in the Gulf of Mexico. The bubbles caught in the chamber have already turned into white methane hydrate at the top. (Photo Credit: NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, Gulf of Mexico 2012 Expedition, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

How Long Would A Bubble Take To Reach The Surface From The Mariana Trench?

Suppose the pellet climbed the whole way. Small bubbles and coated bubbles rise at a steady pace that hardly changes with depth. Sonar in the Black Sea clocked them at about 25 centimeters per second. A robot submarine that chased single bubbles upward off California agreed. Call it a quarter of a meter per second. The climb from the trench floor would take:

  1. 10,935 meters ÷ 0.25 meters per second = about 43,700 seconds
  2. That is a little over 12 hours

Twelve hours is a long commute, and the bubble does not survive it, because it leaks the whole way. Water under pressure can hold far more dissolved gas than water at the surface. You meet that rule every time you open a bottle of soda, and chemists call it Henry's law. At trench pressure the water around the bubble is thirsty for gas, and the bubble is the only supply.

The hydrate shell slows the leak without stopping it. Off California, a bare bubble above the hydrate zone lost about 7.5 micrometers of radius every second. A coated one, nearly two kilometers down, shrank at about a seventh of that rate. It still means a bubble two millimeters in radius, the typical size at a natural seep, is gone in roughly half an hour. By then it has climbed only a few hundred meters.

Bigger bubbles last longer, and the Black Sea shows how far that can go. Above mud volcanoes in the Black Sea, sonar has watched plumes of coated bubbles climb 1,300 meters. They start from a seabed about two kilometers down. Every one of them faded out at a depth of 740 meters, still forty-five meters short of the level where methane hydrate stops being stable. Above that line a bubble has no shell at all and dissolves within minutes. A 1,300-meter climb is about one-eighth of the Mariana Trench.

Methane bubbles streaming off the seabed at a cold seep offshore Virginia, filmed by a NOAA robot. (Photo Credit: NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
Methane bubbles streaming off the seabed at a cold seep offshore Virginia, filmed by a NOAA robot. (Photo Credit: NOAA Okeanos Explorer Program, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

So, Why Does Nothing From The Trench Floor Reach The Surface?

Put the pieces in order and the forum answer falls apart. At 1,100 atmospheres the gas in your bubble is a dense fluid, not a gas. If it is carbon dioxide it is heavier than seawater, so it sinks onto the mud and dissolves there. If it is methane or air it floats, but within seconds it is sealed inside a shell of hydrate. It then crawls upward at a quarter of a meter per second, bleeding gas the whole way. The trench floor is eleven kilometers down. The bubble never sees the part of the ocean where it would have swelled, let alone the surface.

If a lone bubble seems like a weak test, the Gulf of Mexico ran a brutal one in 2010. The Deepwater Horizon blowout happened at a wellhead in more than 5,000 feet of water. Along with the oil, it released on the order of 200,000 metric tons of methane over nearly three months. Surveys across the region found it trapped in a deep layer about a kilometer down, dissolved. Bacteria ate almost all of it there within about four months. Less than one part in ten thousand reached the air. If a gushing well a mile down cannot push gas to the surface, a single bubble starting seven times deeper has no chance.

There is still some mess in the details. Oily bubbles do not behave like clean ones. The depth where a shell forms shifts with temperature. And nobody has released a test bubble at the Challenger Deep and filmed it. But every measurement so far points one way. The deep ocean is a lid, and an excellent one. Whatever was released at the bottom of the Mariana Trench is dissolved, dined on and gone, and nobody at the surface would ever know.

The Deepwater Horizon rig burning in April 2010. The well a mile below released some 200,000 tons of methane, and less than one part in ten thousand of it reached the air. (Photo Credit: U.S. Coast Guard, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
The Deepwater Horizon rig burning in April 2010. The well a mile below released some 200,000 tons of methane, and less than one part in ten thousand of it reached the air. (Photo Credit: U.S. Coast Guard, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)
References (click to expand)
  1. Ambient Sound at Challenger Deep, Mariana Trench, Supplementary Figure S2 (mooring pressure and temperature record) — Oceanography / The Oceanography Society
  2. How deep is the ocean? — NOAA National Ocean Service
  3. Thermophysical Properties of Fluid Systems: Methane — NIST Chemistry WebBook
  4. Thermophysical Properties of Fluid Systems: Carbon dioxide — NIST Chemistry WebBook
  5. Thermophysical Properties of Fluid Systems: Nitrogen — NIST Chemistry WebBook
  6. Gas Hydrate Stability (Open-File Report 96-272, Chapter 2) — U.S. Geological Survey
  7. What are gas hydrates? — NOAA Ocean Exploration
  8. Hydrate Formation on Marine Seep Bubbles and the Implications for Water Column Methane Dissolution — Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans (2021)
  9. Enhanced lifetime of methane bubble streams within the deep ocean — Geophysical Research Letters (2002)
  10. Physicochemical and hydrodynamical controls on methane bubble dissolution within the hydrate stability field — Geophysical Research Abstracts, EGU (2005)
  11. Fate of rising methane bubbles in stratified waters: How much methane reaches the atmosphere? — Journal of Geophysical Research (2006)
  12. Hunting Bubbles: Understanding Plumes of Seafloor Methane — Schmidt Ocean Institute
  13. Permanent carbon dioxide storage in deep-sea sediments — PNAS (2006), via PubMed Central
  14. Lakes of liquid CO2 in the deep sea — PNAS (2006), via PubMed Central
  15. Submarine venting of liquid carbon dioxide on a Mariana Arc volcano — NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory
  16. Natural supersaturation conditions needed for nucleation of air-clathrate hydrates in deep ice sheets — Journal of Glaciology (2014)
  17. A Persistent Oxygen Anomaly Reveals the Fate of Spilled Methane in the Deep Gulf of Mexico — Science (2011)
  18. Deepwater Horizon: the rig and the well — Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Oil in the Ocean